Recount petitions were filed in all 32 precincts of the 41st House District. A Lancaster County judge hears them Thursday
Democrat Brad Chambers leads Republican Rep. Brett Miller by 28 votes in unofficial results. It may be the first legislative recount in state history started by voters in every precinct of a district.
Voters have filed recount petitions in every one of the 32 precincts in Lancaster County's 41st House District, Votebeat and Spotlight PA reported Wednesday. Democrat Brad Chambers leads Republican Rep. Brett Miller 14,291 to 14,263, a 28-vote margin, in unofficial results. A hearing on the petitions is scheduled for 1:30 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, at the Lancaster County Courthouse. President Judge Leonard Brown III has the case.
Why it matters: the race is the closest state House contest of the year, and Votebeat reported it may be the first legislative recount in state history started by voters in every precinct of a district. Democrats keep the House majority either way. According to Associated Press race calls cited by Votebeat, they have won at least 111 seats to Republicans' 89, with the 41st and two other districts still unresolved.
What was filed
- 32 petitions, one per precinct, filed Monday and Tuesday. Each asks for a recount of that precinct's votes from the Nov. 3 election, in similar language, WGAL reported.
- The lawyer. Brian Adrian is listed as counsel for the voters on all 32 petitions. WGAL identified him as counsel for the House Republican Campaign Committee. He didn't return calls from Votebeat or WGAL.
- Who asked. LNP | LancasterOnline reported that Republican voters said Miller asked them to file. Miller didn't return Votebeat's call and hasn't conceded. Chambers said the two haven't spoken.
- A hand count. The petitioners asked for a hand recount, which state law doesn't require. In a 2022 primary, a judge turned down a hand-recount request for one precinct in another House district, and that county recounted by machine, Votebeat reported.
How a recount petition works
Pennsylvania has no automatic recount for legislative races. Three voters in a precinct can ask the county court to recount it by alleging error or fraud; each petition costs $50, Votebeat reported. A 2023 state Supreme Court ruling held that a petition must either make a specific allegation of fraud or be filed in every precinct of the district. Covering every precinct is what lets these petitions go forward without a fraud claim. Chambers said Miller isn't alleging fraud or error, CBS 21 reported.
Adam Bonin, an election lawyer working for the House Democratic Campaign Committee on Chambers' behalf, told Votebeat he knows of no state House race, or any larger race, where petitioners have managed to file in every precinct. Our recount explainer covers the earlier steps.
Could it change the result?
Recounts rarely flip races. A FairVote study cited by Votebeat found recounts changed the winner of three statewide elections this century, all with first-count margins under 0.06 percentage points. The 41st's margin is 0.10 points. Totals can still shift, because people may read a ballot mark differently than a scanner did.
"Absolutely, I would accept the outcome of the recount," Chambers told Votebeat. Bonin said, "If Republicans want to go through the effort of a recount, we will go through that."
The calendar
- Nov. 19, 1:30 p.m.: court hearing on the 32 petitions.
- Nov. 23: the state deadline for counties to certify results. The Department of State has said counties can delay certification while recount petitions are pending, Votebeat reported.
- Nov. 30: Miller's current term ends with the 2025-26 session.
- Dec. 1: members elected Nov. 3 take office.
Our last update on the count has the earlier timeline. All vote figures here are unofficial.