Pennsylvania's aging secretary disputes an elder abuse audit. Two Senate bills on the same system are waiting in the House
Senate Bill 1376, which would set new standards for county elder abuse investigations, passed 33-16 on a split vote. An elder abuse registry bill passed 42-8 last week. A broader House rewrite has been on the House table since September.
Aging Secretary Jason Kavulich says a state audit of how his department oversees elder abuse investigations is inaccurate, but he acknowledged the department needs to improve, WITF reported Thursday. "We need to do a better job," he told the station.
Why it matters: county Area Agencies on Aging investigate reports of abuse, neglect and financial exploitation of people 60 and older. The Department of Aging is supposed to make sure those 52 agencies do the job well and on time. The audit says that oversight has gaps.
What the audit found
Auditor General Tim DeFoor's office reviewed the department's oversight from January 2024 through June 2025 and made 10 findings, WITF reported. DeFoor said the department treats legal deadlines for abuse investigations as a goal rather than a requirement, and he cited long delays in getting documents and scheduling interviews during the audit.
Spotlight PA reported that the audit found the department monitors counties every 18 months rather than every year as state law requires, and that it had monitored 36 of the 52 agencies between early 2025 and Oct. 9 of this year. The department rejected most of the audit's 39 recommendations and said its release weeks before an election was political, Spotlight reported.
Kavulich told WITF the audit judged the department's new monitoring system, CAPE, at its earliest stage. The 2026-27 state budget includes $1 million for the department to keep improving it, WITF reported. The auditor general can't impose penalties. The legislature can change the law.
What the records add
The Senate's oversight bill. Senate Bill 1376, from Sen. Jarrett Coleman (R-Lehigh), would rewrite the Department of Aging's duties toward county agencies and set new performance measures. Spotlight reported one would check whether investigations covered every area of abuse, neglect or exploitation. Sens. Wayne Langerholc and Tracy Pennycuick are co-sponsors.
- Aging and Youth Committee, June 9, 2026: 7-4. All seven Republicans voted yes. Democratic Sens. Maria Collett, Carolyn Comitta, Patty Kim and James Malone voted no.
- Appropriations Committee, Sept. 29: amended and reported 14-8.
- Final passage, Sept. 30: 33-16.
It was sent to the House Aging and Older Adult Services Committee the same day and has not moved since. A House Democratic spokesperson told Spotlight, "We're reviewing the bill."
An elder abuse registry. Senate Bill 807, "Alice's Law," from Sen. Lynda Schlegel Culver (R-Northumberland), would create a statewide Older Adult Abuse Registry under the Older Adults Protective Services Act, with penalties, according to its bill page. The same four Democrats voted against a committee amendment (7-4) before the committee reported it 11-0 on Sept. 30. The Senate passed it 42-8 on Oct. 21. Its bill page lists no House action yet.
Advertisement
The House's own rewrite. House Bill 1611, from Rep. Maureen Madden (D-Monroe), is a broad update of the Older Adults Protective Services Act, with 23 Democratic co-sponsors. On June 8, the House Aging committee rejected a motion to table it 12-14 and reported it 17-9. It went to the Rules Committee, came back Sept. 8, and was laid on the table that day. It has had no floor vote.
What happens next
The House has two voting days left, Nov. 9 and 10, according to its session calendar. Bills that don't pass both chambers by Nov. 30 die. The department has three months to respond to the audit in writing, Spotlight reported.
Anyone who suspects an older adult is being abused can call the state's 24-hour line at 1-800-490-8505, as the Department of Aging lists.