On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

General AssemblyElections

An AI-made video of Shapiro is legal under Pennsylvania law. A House deepfake bill passed 203-0 and has waited 492 days in the Senate

House Bill 811 would require disclosures on AI-faked campaign ads and let candidates sue over them. No member of the House voted against it in June 2025, and the Senate committee that received it has not acted since.

Republican candidate for governor Stacy Garrity released a video this month in which an AI-generated version of Gov. Josh Shapiro walks through the doors of the governor's office and refers to sexual harassment scandals while a real New York Times headline about a Shapiro aide appears on screen, WPSU reported in a story published by WITF. The video has no on-screen label. The simulated Shapiro says he is artificial only about 45 seconds in.

Why it matters: Pennsylvania has no law that bans deepfakes in political ads or requires them to be labeled, the report said. Neighboring Delaware, Maryland and New York have laws that do one or the other. With Election Day on Tuesday, voters may see more ads like this one, and nothing in state law requires them to say what is real.

A Shapiro spokesperson called the ad "cheap" and "dishonest" in a statement to Axios, and Garrity told KDKA-TV she stands by it, according to the WPSU report. The Philadelphia Inquirer also looked this week at how AI attack ads build on older direct-mail tactics.

What the records add

The bill. House Bill 811, from Rep. Tarik Khan, a Philadelphia Democrat, would create civil liability for "fraudulent misrepresentation of candidates" and set penalties. Its sponsorship memo is titled "Prohibiting the Misuse of Artificial Intelligence in Campaigns." House Republicans described it as requiring a clear disclosure on deepfake campaign ads in the 90 days before an election (House Republican Caucus).

It has 34 co-sponsors: 32 Democrats and two Republicans, Reps. Jeremy Shaffer of Allegheny County and Craig Williams of Delaware County.

Every House vote was unanimous.

  • Communications and Technology Committee, June 3, 2025: amended and reported, 26-0.
  • Rules Committee, June 17, 2025: 33-0.
  • Appropriations Committee, June 23, 2025: 37-0.
  • Final passage, June 23, 2025: 203-0.

Then it stopped. The bill was sent to the Senate Communications and Technology Committee on June 24, 2025. The bill page shows no action since then: 492 days as of Thursday. The committee has held no vote on it.

The Senate's own idea. Sen. Lisa Boscola, a Lehigh Valley Democrat, circulated a memo in May saying she would introduce a bill to bar AI-generated or AI-altered video, audio and images of a candidate in the 90 days before an election. As of this week it had not been introduced, WPSU reported.

A law that doesn't reach campaigns. Shapiro signed Senate Bill 806 this month, now Act 99 of 2026, which requires disclosure when AI is used in advertising for goods and services. It doesn't cover campaign ads. Our Oct. 24 article covers that vote.

What happens next

The Senate has two scheduled voting days left, Nov. 17 and 18, according to its session calendar. For HB 811 to become law, it would need committee action and three readings by then. Any bill that hasn't passed both chambers when the session ends Nov. 30 dies, and its sponsor would have to start over in January.

Voters who want to report a misleading election communication can contact the Department of State's hotline at 1-877-VOTESPA, as vote.pa.gov lists. Nothing in state law now makes an unlabeled AI ad, on its own, a violation.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime