On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State HouseEthics

A House committee voted 33-0 to censure Rep. Aaron Bernstine. The full House could vote Nov. 19, a session day leaders just added

HR 676 cites reports of Bernstine's conduct "since 2020 and as recently as September 2026." Bernstine, reelected last week, has called the latest allegations false. The House may have censured a member only twice before, both in the 1870s.

The House Rules Committee voted 33-0 on Tuesday to send the full House a resolution censuring Rep. Aaron Bernstine, a Republican who represents parts of Butler and Lawrence counties. Every Democrat and every Republican on the committee voted yes, including Republican Leader Jesse Topper, according to the committee's roll call.

Why it matters: censure is rare. Pennsylvania's House may have censured only two members in its history, in 1875 and 1879, WESA reported. The House was not scheduled to vote again until January; leaders added a Nov. 19 voting session, when the full House could take up the resolution.

What the resolution says

House Resolution 676 is short. It says that "since 2020 and as recently as September 2026, there have been multiple public reports of conduct allegedly engaged in by Representative Aaron Bernstine" that fall below the standard expected of public officials. It notes that a legislative body may discipline a member through "reprimand, censure or expulsion," or by limiting privileges under House rules.

Its one operative line, citing Article II, Section 11 of the state constitution, would have the House "censure Representative Aaron Bernstine for his actions which are unbecoming of a member of the House of Representatives." That section lets each chamber punish members for disorderly behavior and, with a two-thirds vote, expel one. The resolution itself imposes no other penalty.

The bill text lists Majority Leader Matt Bradford as the sponsor and says the resolution originated in the Rules Committee on Nov. 10. Bradford chairs the committee and made the motion. WESA reported that Speaker Joanna McClinton introduced the measure. A spokesperson for Bradford did not say whether further sanctions were possible, WESA reported.

"The standard applies to both caucuses," Bradford said, according to WESA, adding that the speaker had been clear that every member must meet it.

The allegations

PennLive reported in early October that Bernstine used homophobic slurs about Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta, a Philadelphia Democrat, during an argument at a Harrisburg pub near the Capitol. Kenyatta was not there, WITF reported at the time. Kenyatta attended Tuesday's committee meeting but is not a member of the committee, WESA reported.

Bernstine denied the report. "The allegations attributed to me are false. This is a political attack," he said, according to WITF. He said the conversation turned into physical threats against him and that he reported them to law enforcement.

Kenyatta called for Bernstine to resign, and leaders of the Legislative Black and Equality caucuses condemned the alleged conduct, WITF reported. House Republican leaders called the report "troubling" without confirming it. Bernstine resigned his committee assignments before the election, WESA reported.

The resolution's reference to 2020 matches an earlier episode: Bernstine posted a video encouraging his young son to smoke a cigar and use vulgar language, and later apologized after Republican leaders called for him to step down, WESA reported.

Reelected last week

Voters returned Bernstine to the House on Nov. 3 for a sixth two-year term, according to WESA, based on unofficial returns. He was present for Tuesday's master roll call and both floor votes (roll call 1624).

Like every pending bill and resolution, HR 676 expires if it isn't adopted before the 2025-26 session ends Nov. 30. It was listed on Tuesday's supplemental calendar but was not called for a vote before the House adjourned at 6:23 p.m., according to the parliamentarian's daily session update.

What happens next

The House returns Nov. 19, according to its session page. Our session story has what else is waiting.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime