On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

Election 2026Election administration

A congressman asks a court to remove a Bucks County commissioner from the election board. Here's what state law says about who sits on it

Under the Election Code, county commissioners serve as the election board and are replaced only when they're on the ballot. A hearing on Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick's petition is set for Monday morning.

U.S. Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick, a Bucks County Republican, filed a petition Thursday in the Bucks County Court of Common Pleas asking a judge to remove Democratic County Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia from the county's board of elections before Tuesday's vote, WHYY reported. Fitzpatrick faces Democratic Commissioner Bob Harvie in the 1st Congressional District.

Why it matters: county election boards run Pennsylvania elections, including handling disputed ballots and certifying results for state House, state Senate, governor and Congress. How those boards are made up is set by state law, and this case asks a court to change one board's membership four days before an election.

What the petition alleges

The petition alleges that Ellis-Marseglia has a conflict of interest because she publicly supports Harvie, and argues her role creates an appearance of impropriety, WHYY reported. It cites her 2024 comments about counting undated or misdated mail ballots, for which she later apologized, as well as surveillance footage that it says shows her removing copies of a newspaper with an ad criticizing Harvie, photos of her placing Harvie signs and her holding a "Fire Fitz" sign at a rally. Those are allegations in a court filing; no court has ruled on them.

"Voters deserve to have fair elections overseen by fair and impartial judges," Fitzpatrick's campaign said, according to WHYY.

The county's response

In an Oct. 28 letter, County Solicitor Dan Grieser told Fitzpatrick's lawyer that the request has no basis in the Election Code, WHYY reported. "No provision of the Election Code authorizes removal or disqualification of a commissioner," the letter said. Grieser wrote that Ellis-Marseglia has served on the board for 15 general elections, recused herself in years she was on the ballot and voted to certify all five of Fitzpatrick's election wins.

Harvie called the suit an attempt "to sow doubt in the administration of an election," WHYY reported.

What state law says

Section 301 of the Pennsylvania Election Code makes each county's commissioners its board of elections. When a commissioner is "a candidate for nomination or election to any public office," the president judge of the county court appoints a judge or a county voter to serve in that commissioner's place. Harvie stepped off the board after launching his congressional campaign, WHYY reported.

The statute doesn't list other grounds for replacing a commissioner on the board, such as supporting a candidate, which is the point the county's solicitor made. Fitzpatrick's petition instead argues due process and the appearance of impropriety, according to WHYY. Some home rule counties have their own rules; Allegheny County's charter, for example, also bars a board member who becomes a candidate from acting on the board.

What the records add

The General Assembly has not changed how county election boards are composed this session. The broad Election Code bill that has moved furthest, House Bill 1396, deals with mail ballots, drop boxes, audits and early voting rather than board membership, and has sat in the Senate since May 2025, as our Oct. 29 article explains.

What happens next

A hearing is scheduled for 9 a.m. Monday, Nov. 2, WHYY reported. A judge would have to act before Tuesday for the board's membership to change for this election. Voting in Bucks County proceeds as scheduled either way: polls are open 7 a.m. to 8 p.m., and mail ballots must reach the county by 8 p.m. Tuesday.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime