Consumer advocate asks utility regulators to reconsider the FirstEnergy supplier ruling. Here is the part of the plan the PUC did approve
The Public Utility Commission let FirstEnergy stop guaranteeing payment to suppliers that charge more than its default price, but kept automatic contract renewals in place for now. The state Office of Consumer Advocate wants more.
The state Office of Consumer Advocate has asked the Public Utility Commission to reconsider its October decision on FirstEnergy Pennsylvania's retail supplier rules, according to a Spotlight PA report republished by WITF. The petition also asks for details on the statewide review the PUC ordered, including whether it would involve sworn testimony and legal discovery.
Why it matters: FirstEnergy serves more than 2 million Pennsylvania customers under the Met-Ed, Penelec, Penn Power and West Penn Power names. How suppliers are paid and how their contracts renew affects what those customers pay. Our earlier article covered the piece the PUC turned down. The fuller account shows the 3-2 vote also changed the rules.
What the PUC approved
Utilities like FirstEnergy buy suppliers' customer bills and collect the money, a "purchase of receivables" program. When shoppers don't pay, the utility's other customers end up covering the debt. FirstEnergy's data showed that from 2022 to 2025, 40% of its residential uncollectible debt came from customers on retail suppliers, though only 18% of customers shopped.
The commission agreed to limit the program to supplier contracts priced at or below FirstEnergy's default service. Its written order cited "clear and substantial" evidence of harm from suppliers' "unrestricted access to guaranteed upfront payment." Suppliers argued in filings that the change amounts to a price cap that would make it impossible to do business in Pennsylvania.
What it rejected
The PUC turned down FirstEnergy's request to return customers to default service when their supplier contracts end unless they actively sign up again, and its proposed limits on variable-rate plans. It ordered a statewide review instead, with recommendations due June 1, 2027. Chair Stephen DeFrank said that review should sort out how much of the extra cost came from customers choosing products like green energy plans and how much from "decision inertia."
Two commissioners dissented. Vice Chair Kimberly Barrow said, "We find ourselves squarely in the middle of an affordability crisis and the customers are asking for relief." Commissioner Kathryn Zerfuss called the decision "a missed opportunity."
The numbers behind it
In 2025, FirstEnergy customers who shopped paid $82 million more than they would have on default service, even counting those who saved, and were more than nine times as likely to have their power shut off, according to company data in the case. FirstEnergy said supplier complaints rose 50% in 2025. Before the vote, the Retail Energy Supply Association ran a mail campaign urging residents, "Don't let Harrisburg take your choice away."
The legislature's role
Senate Bill 312, from Sen. John Kane, a Delaware and Chester County Democrat, would change contract-expiration rules by law. It has sat in the Senate Consumer Protection and Professional Licensure Committee since Feb. 26, 2025, and isn't on the Senate's Nov. 17 calendar, so it dies Nov. 30. Kane's party takes control of the Senate in January.
The PUC's docket for the case did not yet show the reconsideration petition when we checked. Customers who use a supplier can compare their rate with the utility's "price to compare" at the PUC's PAPowerSwitch site.