A House bill letting towns pause data center reviews passed 201-1. It has sat in a Senate committee for 139 days
Incoming Democrats say they want local moratoriums, and maybe a statewide one. Three pause bills are already on file this session. None is on the Senate's last calendar, and all three die Nov. 30.
Newly elected Democrats say anger over data centers helped them win, and that pausing new projects is high on their list for January. "Whether it's 180 days or three years," Sen.-elect Eileen Hartnett Albillar of Bucks County told Inside Climate News, "we need to give communities time to be able to revisit their township ordinances." Sen.-elect Brian Wrightson of the 40th District said he would support either.
Those two numbers come from bills already filed this session. A third would let towns pause for 18 months. None of the three is on the Senate's calendar for Tuesday, one of its last two voting days, and all of them die when the session ends Nov. 30.
Why it matters: Pennsylvania's Municipalities Planning Code generally requires towns to make room for every kind of land use, and local officials facing a large proposal have no clear power to stop the clock while they write rules. Which version of a pause becomes law decides how much time they get, and for which projects.
The three bills
House Bill 2496: a 180-day local pause. From Rep. Paul Friel, a Chester County Democrat, it would let a municipality adopt a resolution pausing review of data center applications for up to 180 days while it adopts or changes its ordinances. Its bill history shows:
- House Local Government Committee, June 17: 26-0.
- House final passage, June 24: 201-1. Its 42 co-sponsors include 18 Republicans.
- Senate Local Government Committee, June 30: amended and reported 11-0, then first consideration and re-referral to Rules and Executive Nominations.
It has sat in Senate Rules for 139 days. Because the Senate amended it, the House would also have to vote again, and the House's only remaining date, Nov. 19, is listed as non-voting.
Senate Bill 1345: an 18-month local moratorium. From Sen. Jarrett Coleman, a Lehigh County Republican, it would let municipalities stop accepting new applications for "high impact" data centers. The Local Government Committee reported it 10-1 on June 30, and the Rules Committee amended and reported it 13-4 on July 11. It got second consideration July 12 and has been back in Rules since Sept. 30, according to its bill history. As a Senate bill, it would still need three House considerations, which the House can't finish. Coleman lost his seat Nov. 3 (our article), as did his co-sponsor Tracy Pennycuick.
Senate Bill 1359: a three-year statewide pause. From Sen. Katie Muth, a Democrat from the Berks-Montgomery-Chester 44th District, it would impose a statewide moratorium on hyperscale data center development and permitting. Its co-sponsors are Democrats Carolyn Comitta, Nikil Saval and Amanda Cappelletti and Republican Rosemary Brown. It was referred to Local Government on June 4 and has had no committee vote in 165 days (bill history). At the June 30 meeting, the committee rejected an amendment to SB 1345 on a 2-9 vote; The Center Square and others reported that Brown had tried to swap in the statewide moratorium. Brown also lost Nov. 3, to Wrightson (our article).
What is on Tuesday's calendar
The data center bill that is listed is SB 1408, Pennycuick's transparency bill, which bans certain nondisclosure agreements between public agencies and data centers and sets public-input and reporting rules. It's up for third consideration, but as a Senate bill it can't clear the House this session (our explainer).
Advertisement
What's next
New bills start over in January with new numbers. Inside Climate News reported that Rep.-elect Jeff Warren (137th District) and Rep.-elect Sara Agerton (88th District) think 180 days is too short, and that Warren would vote for a two- or five-year pause if leaders brought one up. David Masur of PennEnvironment warned that with a 26-24 Senate, "If you lose a single Democrat in the Senate, you can't pass anything."
Franklin & Marshall pollster Berwood Yost told WESA that about 80% of voters in an August poll said they would oppose a data center in their community, and that no party split has shown up on the issue. The Data Center Coalition told Inside Climate News that the industry wants to "support responsible data center growth."
Inside Climate News counted 27 data center projects somewhere in the state's permitting process. Gov. Josh Shapiro's order lets developers get state permits only after local approval. As of Nov. 10, no developer had signed on to his GRID standards (our article).