On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State SenateElections

Data centers are the fight in two state Senate races. Here's what Pennycuick's and Bartolotta's bills and votes show

In the 24th District, Tracy Pennycuick's challenger is attacking a bill she co-sponsored. In the 46th, Camera Bartolotta's permitting bill is the target. Neither bill has had a floor vote.

Data centers have become a central issue in at least two state Senate races that could help decide which party controls the chamber, according to reporting this week by Spotlight PA and WESA.

Why it matters: both seats are held by Republicans. Democrats need to flip seats to take the Senate majority, and Lehigh University political scientist Chris Borick told Spotlight it is hard to see a path for them without flipping Republican seats in the Berks and Montgomery County area.

The 24th District: Pennycuick vs. Thomas

Sen. Tracy Pennycuick (R-Montgomery), first elected in 2022, faces Democrat Chris Thomas, a volunteer firefighter and former teacher, and Green Party candidate Michael Schonewolf Jr. in a district covering parts of Berks and Montgomery counties, Spotlight reported. Republicans won the last race there by four points. A September poll had Thomas ahead by two, inside its margin of error. The campaigns and party committees spent about $9 million combined from Sept. 15 to Oct. 19.

Thomas's ads call Pennycuick "Big Tech's best buddy in Harrisburg." A Senate Republican committee ad says Thomas's "real bosses" are data center developers, pointing to his campaign's past work for an engineering firm that had consulted for Amazon. Thomas's campaign said that work came after the Amazon job, Spotlight reported. Both candidates now favor limits rather than a moratorium. "Let the local community decide," Pennycuick told the outlet.

What the records show:

  • SB 939, the bill Thomas's campaign focuses on, is Sen. Greg Rothman's (R-Cumberland), with Pennycuick and Sen. Joe Vogel as co-sponsors. It was introduced July 14, 2025. On Feb. 4, 2026, the Communications and Technology Committee adopted an amendment 10-0; Spotlight reported that it stripped the bill's fast-track permitting and zoning provisions. Nothing has happened since: 268 days.
  • SB 1408, Pennycuick's bill, would ban nondisclosure agreements between public agencies and data center developers, require energy and water reporting, and bar development by certain foreign entities. It cleared committee 11-0 on Sept. 29 and Rules 16-0 on Oct. 5. It still needs a final Senate vote.
  • SB 1473, her bill on data centers supplying their own power, was referred to committee Sept. 24 with no action since.

The 46th District: Bartolotta vs. Borello

In Washington, Greene and part of Beaver counties, three-term Sen. Camera Bartolotta (R-Washington) faces independent Jodi Borello, a former staffer at the Center for Coalfield Justice who calls data centers "the number-one issue," WESA reported. An independent poll this month showed them tied.

What the records show: Borello's allies target SB 991, Bartolotta's "Accelerated Data Center Permitting" bill. Bartolotta told WESA it speeds the cleanup and reuse of brownfields and that critics misread it. It was referred to the Environmental Resources and Energy Committee on Sept. 5, 2025, and has had no vote in 420 days.

Votes both senators cast

  • HB 1667, June 25: The Senate's version of this tax bill passed 44-6. Pennycuick and Bartolotta voted yes; the six no votes were all Democrats. That version would have repealed the data center sales tax exemption, Spotlight has reported. WESA reported that Bartolotta, like nearly every senator, has supported data center tax breaks.
  • HB 2496, which would let local governments temporarily pause data center development, passed the House 201-1, with Rep. Eric Nelson (R-Westmoreland) the only no. The Senate Local Government Committee approved an amended version 11-0 on June 30 and sent it to Rules, where it has sat for 122 days.

In the governor's race, Gov. Josh Shapiro and Treasurer Stacy Garrity have accused each other of flip-flopping on data centers, WESA reported.

What happens next

Election Day is Nov. 3. The Senate has two voting days left, Nov. 17 and 18 (calendar). SB 1408 and HB 2496 are each a few steps from a final Senate vote; unpassed bills die Nov. 30. Our Oct. 23 article covers the other targeted Senate seats.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime