The Justice Department sued Penn State over in-state tuition for some undocumented students. Days later, the university projected a $124 million shortfall
Penn State's tuition rule is its own policy, not a state law. The federal suit follows six others that ended state policies elsewhere.
The U.S. Department of Justice sued Penn State on Thursday, Nov. 5, over its policy of charging in-state tuition to some students who are in the country illegally, the Associated Press reported in a story published by Spotlight PA. The complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, Higher Ed Dive reported.
Why it matters: Penn State is one of the state-related universities that receive an annual appropriation from the General Assembly, and the policy is set by the university, not by state statute. The case puts a federal challenge on a Pennsylvania institution as the new Democratic majorities prepare for the 2027-28 budget.
What the suit says
The federal government argues that federal law bars giving immigrants in the country illegally a postsecondary benefit based on residency unless the same benefit is available to all U.S. citizens. It asks the court to bar Penn State from applying in-state rates to undocumented students and from adopting any new policy that favors them over citizens, according to the Justice Department's announcement.
The department works to ensure "no state law or university policy gives preferential treatment to illegal aliens," Stanley Woodward, a top Justice Department official, said in a release, the AP reported.
Penn State's policy
Undocumented students can qualify for in-state tuition if they meet the university's residency requirements, which include attending a Pennsylvania high school for at least four years and graduating or earning a GED in the state, WPSU reported. A Penn State spokesperson said the university is reviewing the complaint.
Supporters of such policies argue they don't violate federal law because U.S. citizens in the same circumstances, state residents who graduated from a state high school, get the same rate, the AP reported. A report from TheDream.US and other advocacy groups said in-state tuition policies expand access to higher education, WPSU reported.
Elsewhere
This is the Justice Department's 27th such lawsuit, Higher Ed Dive reported. Earlier suits produced orders favorable to the government in Texas, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Illinois and Kansas. The department sued the University of Delaware in early October. Illinois has since passed a law restoring access starting in 2027, WPSU reported.
The budget news
On Monday, Nov. 9, Penn State said it expects a $124 million shortfall this fiscal year in its $2.2 billion education and general budget, StateCollege.com reported. The university attributed it to enrollment declines, total enrollment down 3,058, including 2,384 fewer out-of-state students, 922 fewer international students and 742 fewer graduate students, and to employee health insurance claims that rose 15.7% and cost $37 million more than projected. Lower enrollment cut projected tuition and fee revenue by about $87 million.
Advertisement
About half the enrollment drop is at the seven Commonwealth Campuses set to close after the spring semester, StateCollege.com reported. The university plans cuts averaging about 1.25% in units funded by the education budget, limited to non-personnel spending, and other steps. It said it has no plans for a universitywide cut to programs or services.
What happens next
Penn State is expected to answer the complaint in federal court. The suit does not involve the legislature directly. The state budget, including Penn State's appropriation, is next due July 1, 2027.