EPA watchdog will review the East Palestine response. Pennsylvania's rail safety bill has waited 212 days in the Senate
The derailment on the Ohio-Pennsylvania border led to a House bill on train length, crew size and blocked crossings. It passed 120-79 in March and hasn't had a Senate committee vote.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's inspector general will examine how the agency handled the February 2023 Norfolk Southern derailment in East Palestine, Ohio, including whether it had enough data to back up its public assurances that residents could safely go home, Spotlight PA reported Wednesday.
Why it matters: East Palestine sits on the Ohio-Pennsylvania border, Spotlight noted. Since the derailment, the Pennsylvania House has twice passed rail safety bills in response. Neither has had a Senate vote.
What the watchdog will look at
The inspector general's review will cover the agency's handling of the disaster and the health and environmental concerns raised since, according to Spotlight PA. Testing experts have questioned whether the data the EPA shared masked risks from the mix of chemicals involved. Spotlight reported that a recent request from Vice President JD Vance and the EPA's administrator helped start the review, following years of complaints from residents.
The train derailed after a bearing failed. Three days later, officials decided to vent and burn five rail cars carrying vinyl chloride, a step the National Transportation Safety Board later found was unnecessary, Spotlight reported.
Two settlements remain unsettled. A $600 million class action settlement with residents is tied up in court, and a federal settlement that includes a $15 million fine and $55 million for medical exams and groundwater testing has waited more than two years for a judge's approval. Norfolk Southern is also seeking an $85 billion merger with Union Pacific, which is before the federal Surface Transportation Board, according to the same report.
What the records add
House Bill 1191. HB 1191, from Rep. Rob Matzie, a Beaver County Democrat, would:
- bar trains from blocking road crossings;
- cap the length of freight and work trains (8,500 feet, according to the SMART transportation union);
- set minimum crew levels, including two-person crews;
- require working wayside detectors, the trackside sensors meant to catch problems like overheated bearings;
- require study and reporting on hazardous materials shipped by rail, and set penalties.
It has 28 co-sponsors. Here is its path:
- House Consumer Protection, Technology and Utilities Committee, Dec. 16, 2025: reported 23-3.
- House floor amendment, March 24, 2026: adopted 196-3.
- House Appropriations, March 25: 22-15.
- Final passage, March 25: 120-79.
- Senate: referred to the Consumer Protection and Professional Licensure Committee on March 30. The bill page shows no action since: 212 days as of Wednesday.
This is the second try. A similar bill, HB 1028, passed the House 141-62 in June 2023 and was never voted on in the Senate, according to SMART. When HB 1191 passed this spring, Matzie said, "We can't sit around and wait for that to happen again," and called on the Senate to act, the union reported.
What happens next
The Senate's last two scheduled voting days are Nov. 17 and 18, according to its session calendar. HB 1191 is not on a committee agenda. If it isn't enacted by Nov. 30, it would have to be reintroduced in January, which would be the third session in a row.