On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

EducationGovernor

Shapiro has until Jan. 1 to decide whether Pennsylvania joins the federal scholarship tax credit. A Senate plan to force it was never filed

The credit gives donors up to $1,700 back for gifts to scholarship groups, but students benefit only in states whose governors opt in. Thirty-one states had by mid-October. Shapiro said he was "very open" and would decide in weeks.

Gov. Josh Shapiro has seven weeks to decide whether Pennsylvania joins the federal scholarship tax credit program. Governors have until Jan. 1, 2027, to opt their states in for the first year, Chalkbeat Philadelphia reported. As of Thursday we found no announcement from his office.

Supporters of the program are stepping up pressure on Shapiro to opt in before the deadline, CapitolWire reported this week, according to PoliticsPA's Thursday Playbook.

Why it matters: under the federal law, the governor makes the choice, and it can't wait for the new Democratic legislature, which convenes Jan. 5. A state law requiring Pennsylvania to take part was proposed in the Senate in August, but no bill was ever filed.

How the credit works

The program comes from the federal tax law signed in July 2025, which the Senate memo below calls the Working Families Tax Cuts Act. Starting with contributions made on or after Jan. 1, 2027:

  • The credit: a taxpayer who gives to a scholarship granting organization gets a federal tax credit for the gift, up to $1,700 for an individual, or $3,400 for a married couple, Metro Philadelphia reported Oct. 18.
  • The scholarships: families with incomes under 300% of their area's median income, adjusted for family size, are eligible, Metro reported. Scholarships can cover private school tuition and other education costs, such as tutoring, special education services and supplies, at private or public schools, according to the Senate memo below.
  • Opting in: only students in states whose governors opt in can receive the scholarships. Residents of states that stay out can still claim the credit, but their money would go to organizations elsewhere.

Treasury and the IRS released regulations Oct. 1, Metro reported. Thirty-one states had opted in by mid-October, including two with Democratic governors, New York and Colorado, according to Chalkbeat.

What Shapiro has said

At an Oct. 7 debate, Shapiro said he was "very open" to opting in and expected to announce a decision "in the next few weeks," Metro and Chalkbeat reported. "I think prudence here makes the most sense," he said, according to Chalkbeat. His administration was "continuing to digest" the rules, and a spokesperson pointed Chalkbeat to his debate answer when asked for comment.

His opponent, Treasurer Stacy Garrity, said she would opt in "on day one." Shapiro won by 22 points, according to unofficial results (our article).

The legislature's role

The General Assembly can't make the choice for him, but some senators tried to. On Aug. 5, Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward circulated a co-sponsorship memo for a bill to "ensure Pennsylvania families and parents can benefit" from the federal credit. Its listed backers were Republican Sens. Joe Pittman, Scott Martin, Lynda Schlegel Culver and Judy Ward, and one Democrat, Sen. Anthony Williams of Philadelphia. The memo page still says the legislation "has not been submitted." With the Senate's last voting days on Nov. 17 and 18, it can't pass this session.

Williams told Chalkbeat that if Pennsylvania stays out, "the program will still exist" and the money will leave the state.

The other side

A coalition of 17 civic and education groups sent Shapiro a letter urging him to reject the program, saying it would "fuel discrimination against students," Chalkbeat reported. Susan Spicka of Education Voters of PA said the vouchers "will benefit wealthy families." Critics also argue it sends federal tax money to private schools, most of them religious, Metro reported.

The state programs already in place

Pennsylvania already runs two scholarship tax credits for businesses, the Educational Improvement Tax Credit and the Opportunity Scholarship Tax Credit, which the same scholarship organizations use. Critics told Chalkbeat the federal program's income limits clash with the state programs'.

We'll report his decision when it comes.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime