On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State SenateBill guide

Contractors couldn't be made to cover another party's negligence under a House bill that passed 200-1. It needs two Senate votes this week

HB 1541 would void clauses in nonresidential construction contracts that shift liability for an owner's or general contractor's own negligence onto someone else. It has waited on the Senate calendar since June.

House Bill 1541, from Rep. Joe Hohenstein, a Philadelphia Democrat, and Rep. Marla Brown, a Lawrence County Republican, is listed for second consideration on the Senate's Nov. 17 calendar. It passed the House 200-1 in April.

Why it matters: the bill would change the fine print in contracts for building and repairing commercial buildings, roads and other projects, deciding who pays when someone is hurt or property is damaged on a job site. If the Senate passes it unchanged on Tuesday and Wednesday, it would go to Gov. Josh Shapiro.

What it does

Construction contracts often include "indemnification" clauses, in which one party agrees to cover another's legal costs and damages. HB 1541 targets clauses that make a subcontractor or other party cover losses caused by the negligence of the party demanding the clause.

Under the final House text, a term in a construction contract that has an owner or general contractor "indemnified, held harmless or insured" for injuries, property damage or economic damage "caused by or resulting from the indemnitee's negligence, in whole or in part" would be "void as against public policy and unenforceable."

Key details:

  • Nonresidential only. "Construction contract" covers design, inspection, construction, repair, maintenance and site work on a building, road, highway, railroad or other structure under a nonresidential contract or purchase order.
  • Who is protected. The "indemnitee" is an owner, a general contractor or their agent or employee who presents the clause.
  • The law it amends. A 1970 state law already restricts such clauses in contracts with architects, engineers and surveyors and in snow and ice removal agreements. The bill adds construction contracts.
  • Timing. It would take effect 180 days after signing.

The sponsors' co-sponsorship memo said contractors are often required to take on liability for another party's negligence and that 45 states have some form of anti-indemnity law for construction contracts. The House Appropriations Committee's fiscal note found no cost to the state.

The votes

  • House Judiciary Committee, Feb. 4: 26-0 to amend and report the bill.
  • House floor amendments, April 14 and 15: each 201-0.
  • House final passage, April 15: 200-1 (roll call). Rep. Mike Jones, a York County Republican, cast the only no vote.
  • Senate Banking and Insurance Committee, June 9: 13-0 (committee vote).

The bill's 13 co-sponsors include three other Republicans, Jeff Olsommer, Joe Kerwin and Brown, and 10 Democrats.

What happens next

HB 1541 had first consideration in the Senate June 9. On Sept. 28 it was laid on the table and removed the same day, a routine step. It needs second consideration and then a final vote on a separate day; Nov. 17 and 18 are the only Senate session days left. Any Senate amendment would send it back to the House, whose Nov. 19 session is listed as non-voting (our Sunday check).

If it doesn't finish, it dies Nov. 30, 198 days after it reached the Senate. Our Friday article has the full list of bills that could still reach Shapiro.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime