On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State SenateBill guide

Meatpacking safety committees are on the Senate calendar twice, in a House bill and a Senate bill. Neither can become law without the House voting again

HB 1923 would require large meat and food processing plants to set up joint labor-management safety committees and pay for new workers' safety training. The Senate amended it in committee, so the House would have to agree, and its last day is listed as non-voting.

The Senate's Nov. 17 calendar lists two bills with the same title, the Meat Packing and Food Processing Protection Act: House Bill 1923, from Rep. Jim Haddock, a Luzerne County Democrat, and Senate Bill 406, from Sen. Christine Tartaglione, a Philadelphia Democrat.

Why it matters: the bills would set new safety rules for workers at large slaughterhouses, meat and poultry plants and food factories, with daily fines for employers that don't comply. But both are stuck one step short. HB 1923 carries a Senate committee amendment, so the House would have to vote again. SB 406 would need three House votes. The House's only remaining session, Nov. 19, is listed as non-voting (our Sunday check).

What HB 1923 would do

The Senate-amended text covers businesses with 100 or more employees at a single facility, counting temp-agency workers and independent contractors, that are licensed under the state's meat and poultry hygiene law, inspected under federal meat or egg inspection laws, or subject to state food safety law, and registered as a federal food facility. Under the text, employers would have to:

  • Train new workers on job health risks, their right to medical care and workers' compensation, and federal workplace safety rights, during paid hours and in any language spoken by at least 5% of the workforce.
  • Pay out-of-pocket costs for emergency medical transportation when a worker is hurt or becomes ill on the job and needs care that on-site medical staff can't provide.
  • Set up a joint labor-management health and safety committee at each facility, with at least two employer and two employee representatives, to inspect for hazards, review injuries and complaints, and make written proposals. The committees would be "advisory only."

The Department of Labor and Industry would appoint an industry workers' rights coordinator with "full access to facility operations" to investigate complaints. Fines would be $500 a day, rising to as much as $10,000 a day if a violation isn't fixed within 10 days. The text bars retaliation against workers who use these rights, and an employer and union can opt out in writing. It would take effect in 90 days.

For the House-passed version, the House Appropriations Committee's fiscal note estimated state costs of $2.35 million in the first year, including a $2 million complaint database, and about $885,000 the next, for a coordinator, a clerk and an estimated five investigators. We found no Senate fiscal note on palegis.us for the amended version.

The votes

  • House final passage, Feb. 4: 122-76 (roll call). All 100 Democrats voting and 22 Republicans voted yes; 76 Republicans voted no.
  • Senate Labor and Industry Committee, Oct. 7: adopted an amendment 8-2 and reported the bill 8-2 (committee vote).

HB 1923 is listed for second consideration. Tartaglione's SB 406, reported 10-1 by the same committee in June, is listed for third consideration and final passage.

What happens next

Even if the Senate passes HB 1923 by Wednesday, it would return to the House for a concurrence vote. Unless House leaders change the Nov. 19 session, that vote can't happen, and both bills die Nov. 30. They would have to be reintroduced in January, when Democrats control both chambers and the Senate Labor and Industry Committee.

HB 1923 is one of four bills on the calendar that would need the House again; our Friday article lists the others.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime