A House bill would let lenders charge prepayment penalties on investors' home loans. It's the most divided House bill the Senate could still send to Shapiro
HB 2391 keeps the ban on prepayment penalties for mortgages on people's own homes and lifts it for other residential loans. Every House Democrat and 15 Republicans voted yes; 84 Republicans voted no. The Senate needs two days to pass it.
House Bill 2391, from Rep. Scott Conklin, a Centre County Democrat, is listed for second consideration on the Senate's Nov. 17 calendar. If senators take it up Tuesday and give it a final vote Wednesday without changes, it would go to Gov. Josh Shapiro.
Why it matters: the bill changes who is protected by the state's ban on mortgage prepayment penalties, the fees some lenders charge when a borrower pays off a loan early. It passed the House 117-84 in June, the widest split among the House bills on the Senate calendar that could still become law.
What it changes
Section 405 of the Loan Interest and Protection Law, the 1974 state usury law known as Act 6, bars prepayment penalties on residential mortgages. The bill's text would limit that ban to residential mortgages "made primarily for personal, family or household purposes" and signed on or after the bill takes effect.
According to the House Appropriations Committee's fiscal note, a loan "primarily for personal, family, or household use may be paid off early at any time before the loan term ends" without a penalty. Loans for other purposes, such as buying rental property, could carry one. The Department of Banking and Securities told the committee the bill wouldn't cost the state money. It would take effect 60 days after signing.
Conklin's co-sponsorship memo was titled "Housing Affordability Initiative: Lower Investment Costs for Real Estate Investors." It said investors would get "the option of choosing mortgage financing terms with or without a prepayment penalty," which can mean "thousands of dollars saved on closing costs or a lower interest rate," and that the bill "protects mortgages for primary residences and second homes." The memo said the change would help homebuyers and renters but offered no data on prices or rents.
The votes
- House Commerce Committee, April 27: 14-12 (committee vote).
- House Appropriations, June 1: 22-15 (committee vote).
- House final passage, June 8: 117-84 (roll call). All 102 Democrats voting were yes. Republicans split 15 yes, 84 no.
- Senate Banking and Insurance Committee, Oct. 6: 13-1 (committee vote).
The 15 House Republicans who voted yes were Kerry Benninghoff, Joe Emrick, Valerie Gaydos, Joe Hogan, Rich Irvin, R. Lee James, Shelby Labs, Robert Leadbeter, Kristin Marcell, Thomas Mehaffie, Natalie Mihalek, Kathleen Tomlinson, Tim Twardzik, Martina White and Craig Williams. We found no public statement from House Republican leaders explaining the caucus's no votes.
What happens next
The bill had its first Senate consideration Oct. 6. It needs second consideration and then third consideration and final passage on separate days, and only Nov. 17 and 18 are left on the Senate's schedule. Any Senate amendment would send it back to the House, whose Nov. 19 session is listed as non-voting (our Sunday check).
If it doesn't pass unchanged, HB 2391 dies Nov. 30. Our Friday article lists the other bills that could still reach Shapiro.