Independent Fiscal Office: Pennsylvania's structural deficit could top $7 billion by 2030, and the one-time fixes are used up
The office's five-year outlook lands as Democrats prepare their first budget with control of the House, Senate and governor's office. It warns against counting on cannabis or skill-game revenue and against spending the $8 billion Rainy Day Fund.
The state's Independent Fiscal Office released its annual Pennsylvania Fiscal Outlook on Thursday, Nov. 12, with General Fund projections through fiscal 2031-32. The headline: the gap between what the state spends and what it collects each year could exceed $7 billion by 2030 without permanent changes, up from more than $4.5 billion in the last fiscal year, the Pennsylvania Capital-Star reported.
Why it matters: this is the first budget outlook since Democrats won control of the House, Senate and governor's office. Gov. Josh Shapiro will propose a 2027-28 budget early next year, and the deadline is June 30. Promises of a higher minimum wage, more transit money and new health care spending will all be measured against this gap.
What the IFO found
The IFO is an independent office the legislature created in 2010 to produce revenue estimates and budget analysis. Its director, Matthew Knittel, presented the findings Thursday. Here are the main points, as reported by the Capital-Star and republished by WITF:
- The temporary fixes are mostly gone. The current budget was balanced partly by a "cycle roll": two months of payments to Medicaid managed care companies were pushed into the next fiscal year, cutting the year's spending on paper by $2.6 billion. That works once. Federal COVID-19 money is also used up. "Permanent policy changes need to be enacted," Knittel said, "especially if the Rainy Day Fund is to be maintained."
- Revenue growth should cool. Strong corporate profits, driven largely by technology and artificial intelligence companies, pushed corporate net income tax collections above estimates for three years. A one-time boost from taxable tariff refunds added about $230 million. The IFO treats the higher base as permanent but builds in a modest slowdown next year. It is not projecting a recession.
- An older state costs more. The IFO expects retirees to make up a growing share of the population while the school-age and working-age groups shrink, raising spending on services such as health care.
Don't spend the Rainy Day Fund
The Rainy Day Fund holds about $8 billion. Shapiro has proposed in past budgets to draw on it to cover deficits. The IFO says that money should be saved for an emergency such as a recession, not used for recurring costs.
"The difference is the deficits are real, and they're large," Knittel said, noting that the general fund surplus that helped balance recent budgets "is exhausted."
Be careful with new revenue estimates
Democrats can now pass the cannabis legalization and skill-game regulation that the Republican Senate blocked. The Capital-Star reports Shapiro's last budget put the two together at about $2 billion a year. Knittel warned that such estimates carry "a lot of uncertainty and variability" because there is often little data. His example: a 2013 law allowing tavern games was projected to raise about $156 million a year; it brought in $1 million in the latest year.
The IFO suggests budgeting a backup, such as a 0.5 percentage point increase in the personal income or sales tax, that could take effect if new revenue falls short. Other proposals the Capital-Star lists:
- Combined reporting for corporations, which Shapiro's office says could raise up to $1.1 billion a year.
- A 5% tax on digital advertising, proposed by some Democrats and estimated at up to $500 million.
Who will be at the table
Sen. Vincent Hughes will chair the Senate Appropriations Committee under the new Democratic majority (our article). Rep. Jordan Harris keeps the House chair, and Rep. Jamie Barton becomes the House Republicans' Appropriations chair (our article). Senate Republicans haven't named theirs.
Advertisement
Spokespeople for Shapiro and for both parties' leaders did not respond to the Capital-Star's requests for comment.
Our earlier coverage: skill games, transit funding and the minimum wage. Our cannabis article has where those bills stand.