On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

Health careMedicaid

A judge struck the federal 'medically frail' test in a case Pennsylvania joined. Medicaid work rules still start here Jan. 1

The ruling lets people with serious conditions qualify for an exemption without proving the condition keeps them from working. Pennsylvania's Department of Human Services is already mailing notices.

A federal judge in Boston has struck down the narrow definition of "medically frail" that the Trump administration wrote into its rule for Medicaid work requirements, in a lawsuit Pennsylvania joined in June, NBC News reported. The practical effect: people with qualifying conditions won't have to prove those conditions keep them from working in order to be exempt.

Why it matters: starting Jan. 1, 2027, some Pennsylvania adults on Medicaid will have to show 80 hours a month of work or other activities, or qualify for an exemption, to keep their coverage. Being medically frail is one of the main exemptions. How it is defined decides who has to file paperwork and who doesn't.

What the court decided

U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns ruled Oct. 29 that the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services unlawfully narrowed the exemption, NBC reported. The June rule had limited it to people whose condition "significantly impairs the individual's ability to comply" with the work requirement. Congress listed the conditions that qualify, and the states argued those should be enough on their own. The judge left other parts of the rule in place, according to NBC. CMS did not immediately comment.

Pennsylvania was one of 25 states plus Washington, D.C., in the case. Gov. Josh Shapiro joined in his official capacity, Spotlight PA reported when the suit was filed June 29. The states argued the rule would force "vulnerable Medicaid members" through unnecessary hoops.

Before the ruling, the Pennsylvania Health Law Project had warned that under the rule a diagnosis alone wouldn't be enough: a person would also have to show the condition "significantly limits" their ability to meet the requirement. The same advocacy group has estimated that about 310,000 Pennsylvanians could lose coverage from the work rules and more frequent renewals combined. That is an advocates' projection, not a state count.

What Pennsylvania's rules say

According to the Department of Human Services' Medicaid changes page:

  • Who: adults 19 to 64 without a dependent child under 14.
  • What counts: at least 80 hours a month of work, volunteering, job training or part-time school, or monthly income of at least $580.
  • Exemptions include being medically frail (blindness, disability, substance use disorder, disabling mental illness, or serious or complex medical conditions), pregnancy or postpartum coverage, caring for a young child or a person with a disability, recent release from jail or prison, former foster youth under 26, and veterans with a total disability rating.
  • Other changes Jan. 1: some adults will renew every six months instead of yearly, starting after a renewal in or after February 2027, and retroactive coverage shrinks from three months to one month for expansion adults.
  • How to report: 877-395-8930 (215-560-7226 in Philadelphia), COMPASS or the myCOMPASS PA app, or a County Assistance Office. The HR 1 question line is 1-877-883-6383.

The department's page did not mention the Oct. 29 ruling as of this morning.

What the records add

The work requirement comes from federal law, not a state bill. But Pennsylvania lawmakers have voted on the idea before. House Bill 2138 of 2017-18, from Rep. Matthew Dowling (R-Fayette), would have added work requirements to the state's Human Services Code. It passed the House 115-80 on April 17, 2018, and the Senate 30-19 on Oct. 17, 2018. Gov. Tom Wolf vetoed it two days later, Veto No. 2 of 2018, according to its bill page. We did not find a bill this session that would change how the state applies the new federal rules.

What happens next

The federal government can appeal. The judge vacated the "significantly impairs" language as applied to the states that sued, Becker's Payer Issues reported, which includes Pennsylvania. DHS has been sending notices by mail, text and automated calls since August, and anyone who gets a letter asking for information has 30 days to respond, according to the department. People who think they qualify as medically frail should say so when they report, and keep copies of what they send.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime