On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

Election 2026Voting records

Four House Republicans voted for the $15 minimum wage bill. Three of them lost Tuesday, along with at least five other GOP incumbents

Reps. Joe Hogan, KC Tomlinson and Joe Emrick crossed party lines on HB 2189, and Hogan and Tomlinson on the abortion rights amendment. Here is how the defeated incumbents' records compare, without reading the results as a verdict on any one vote.

At least eight Republican state House incumbents lost their seats Tuesday, according to unofficial returns reported by WHYY, the Bucks County Beacon and PoliticsPA. Among them are three of the four Republicans who voted this year for the House's $15 minimum wage bill.

Why it matters: the next House will be more Democratic, and some of the Republicans who most often crossed party lines on high-profile votes won't be in it. The House Republican caucus that returns in January will be smaller, and will include fewer members with a record of crossing over on these bills.

This is a comparison of records, not an explanation of the results. Many things affect a legislative race, including turnout, the top of the ticket and campaign spending, and we don't attribute any outcome to a single vote.

The minimum wage vote

The House passed HB 2189, which would raise the wage to $15 by 2029, 104-95 on March 24. As our Oct. 26 article detailed, four Republicans voted yes: Reps. Joe Emrick, Joe Hogan, Natalie Mihalek and Kathleen "KC" Tomlinson. Two Democrats, Reps. Frank Burns and Christopher Rabb, voted no.

What happened Tuesday, by unofficial returns:

  • Hogan (142nd, Bucks): lost to Democrat Kristin Egan, WHYY reported.
  • Tomlinson (18th, Bucks): lost to Democrat Bryan Allen, the Bucks County Beacon reported.
  • Emrick (137th, Northampton): trailed Democrat Jeff Warren 45.9% to 54.1%, PoliticsPA reported at 1:15 a.m. Wednesday.
  • Mihalek (40th): we haven't found a reported result for her race in the coverage we reviewed.

The abortion rights amendment

On HB 1957, the reproductive rights constitutional amendment, which passed 102-101, the two Republican yes votes were Hogan and Tomlinson, according to an account of the roll call by an opponent of the amendment, the Pennsylvania Family Council, that we reviewed in our Oct. 27 article. Both lost. Two Democrats voted no: Burns and Rep. Anita Kulik, who is retiring.

The other Republican incumbents who lost

These Republicans were also reported defeated, according to unofficial returns:

  • Rep. Craig Williams (160th, Delaware/Chester): lost to Democrat Elizabeth Moro, 45.6% to 54.4% (PoliticsPA).
  • Rep. John Lawrence (13th, Chester): lost to Democrat Madelyn Alvarino, 49.4% to 50.6% (PoliticsPA, WHYY).
  • Rep. Valerie Gaydos (44th, Allegheny): lost to Democrat Hadley Haas, 46.8% to 53.2% (PoliticsPA; PublicSource).
  • Rep. Milou Mackenzie (131st, Lehigh/Montgomery/Northampton): lost to Democrat Meriam Sabih, 49.0% to 51.0% (PoliticsPA, WHYY).
  • Rep. Gary Day (187th, Lehigh/Berks): lost to Democrat Rachel Cuevas, 49.0% to 51.0% (PoliticsPA).

Two more Republican incumbents, Reps. Donna Scheuren (147th) and Shelby Labs (143rd), trailed in races that were still uncalled Wednesday afternoon. One Democratic incumbent, Rep. Brandon Dukes (12th), trailed Republican Scott Timko. Our rundown of uncalled races has the latest counts.

What the records add

The two votes worked differently. On the minimum wage bill, Democrats voted 100-2 in favor, enough to pass it without Republican help; the four Republican yes votes widened the margin to nine. On the abortion amendment, the two Republican yes votes offset the two Democratic no votes, and the measure passed with exactly 102, the minimum needed under Article III, Section 4 of the state constitution.

Both bills are still in Senate committees and die Nov. 30 if the Senate doesn't act. The official House roll call summary pages we cite list totals; the individual crossover votes come from our earlier articles and the accounts cited in them.

What happens next

Every defeated member keeps voting until Nov. 30. The House meets Nov. 9 and 10; our calendar article lists what's scheduled. The new House, with at least 111 Democrats, is sworn in Jan. 5, 2027.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime