On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

ElectionsTrifecta

Democrats' new majorities revive the National Popular Vote compact. Pennsylvania's 19 electoral votes wouldn't be enough to start it

Rep. Heather Boyd plans a bill next session; a Senate version never got past a co-sponsorship memo. States that have joined hold 222 of the 270 electoral votes the compact needs.

Pennsylvania's new Democratic trifecta has revived a proposal that never got a committee vote in Harrisburg: joining the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, the Pennsylvania Capital-Star reported Tuesday, in a story published by WESA. Member states agree to award their electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote, but only once states holding a majority of the Electoral College, 270 votes, have joined.

Why it matters: Pennsylvania's 19 electoral votes are tied for fifth-most, and joining would change how they are awarded. It would also be one of the first tests of what a Democratic legislature takes up beyond the governor's stated priorities.

Where the compact stands

The compact has been enacted in 18 states and the District of Columbia, which together hold 222 electoral votes, the Capital-Star reported. That leaves it 48 short. Neighboring Delaware, New Jersey and New York are members.

The arithmetic: Pennsylvania's 19 would bring the total to 241, still 29 short of 270. Advocates are also looking at Michigan (15), Arizona (11), Wisconsin (10) and Nevada (6), the Capital-Star reported. WITF published a story Tuesday on how Democratic gains in several legislatures this month could affect the compact's chances, and PoliticsPA has an explainer.

Pennsylvania's past bills

  • 2022: Rep. Chris Rabb of Philadelphia introduced a compact bill with eight Democratic co-prime sponsors. Rabb said he wrote it after 19 Pennsylvania Republicans submitted their names as alternate electors in 2020, the Capital-Star reported.
  • 2025-26: Sens. Maria Collett and Katie Muth, both Montgomery County Democrats, circulated a memo seeking co-sponsors but did not introduce a bill. The Capital-Star's story describes no committee vote on any version.
  • 2027-28: Rep. Heather Boyd of Delaware County plans to introduce the bill. "I do think the bill would be more powerful if it were understood by members to be a bipartisan effort," she said, adding she hopes for Republican co-sponsors.

What people are saying

"Pennsylvanians just told us what they want from their government," Collett said, according to the Capital-Star.

Shapiro did not commit to the compact. "I'll work with lawmakers to figure out what the right mechanism is for moving forward on that," he said.

Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to National Popular Vote, the group promoting the compact, said: "Every voter in Pennsylvania should matter in every presidential election." Duquesne University law professor Bruce Ledewitz, who opposes it, called it "an exceedingly undemocratic idea." The Capital-Star's story included no statement from Republican legislators.

What the records add

A compact bill is an ordinary statute: it needs 102 House votes and 26 Senate votes under Article III, Section 4 of the state constitution, and the governor's signature. That is a different path from a constitutional amendment, which skips the governor but needs two sessions and a statewide vote, as our article on Shapiro's promises explains. With 26 Democrats, the Senate would need every Democratic vote, or Republican votes, to pass it.

Bills from the current session die Nov. 30. Any compact bill would be introduced after the new General Assembly convenes Jan. 5.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime