On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

Election 2026Election administration

Pennsylvania's 'early voting' is really one-at-a-time mail voting. The House voted to replace it; a Senate bill would shrink it

State elections official Jonathan Marks called the over-the-counter method 'the most inefficient and painful way of early voting imaginable.' Bills going in opposite directions are both stuck.

Pennsylvania has no in-person early voting. What many voters used this fall instead was "over the counter" mail voting: requesting a mail ballot at a county election office, filling it out and handing it back in one visit. WITF reported, in a story WESA republished Saturday, that county officials say the method strains their staff.

Why it matters: it's the closest thing Pennsylvania has to early voting, and it shapes how fast counties can work in the weeks before and after an election. Two bills would change it in opposite directions, and neither has reached a Senate floor vote.

What election officials said

Each in-person request has to be processed one at a time, unlike online and mailed requests that offices can handle in batches, WITF reported. Jonathan Marks, the Department of State's deputy secretary for elections, said the system is no substitute for real early voting and called it "the most inefficient and painful way of early voting imaginable."

Chris Spackman, who runs elections in Dauphin County, said anyone may use it, though some voters need it more than others. York County President Commissioner Julie Wheeler said serving voters one by one pulls staff from other work. In 2024, some counties had waits of several hours, according to WITF.

More than 1.3 million voters requested mail ballots this year, and 1,114,767 had been returned by 8 a.m. today, according to Department of State figures reported by Spotlight PA. State data doesn't separate over-the-counter ballots in those totals.

What the records add

What state guidance allows. The Department of State's mail ballot guidance says the Election Code lets voters request and submit a mail ballot at the same time before Election Day. Counties may also offer the service at satellite offices, which must be in county- or municipal-owned or leased space, be staffed by county-appointed workers and connect securely to the state voter system. Counties record those requests with a separate code, "CNTR."

The House bill: real early voting. House Bill 1396, from House Speaker Joanna McClinton (D-Philadelphia), would create in-person early voting starting 11 days before an election and ending the Sunday before, with at least one site per county and another for every 100,000 registered voters, Spotlight PA reported when it passed. It passed the House 102-101 on May 13, 2025, with no Republican votes, and has been in the Senate State Government Committee since May 22, 2025.

The Senate bill: fewer places to vote early. Senate Bill 599, from Sen. Cris Dush (R-Jefferson), who chairs that committee, is titled in its sponsor memo "Eliminating Satellite Offices and Dropboxes." It would limit over-the-counter voting to one primary election office in each county seat, WESA reported. Dush said satellite offices "are essentially functioning as polling locations." Its record, from the bill page:

  • April 9, 2025: referred to State Government.
  • June 2, 2026: reported by the committee 7-4, a party-line vote, per WESA.
  • June 30: laid on the table and removed the same day.
  • Oct. 20: laid on the table again under Senate Rule 9.

Its co-sponsors include Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward. It has had no floor vote. A similar Dush bill cleared the committee last session and died, WESA reported.

What happens next

The over-the-counter window for this election closed with the Oct. 27 application deadline. Today, completed mail ballots must reach county offices or drop boxes by 8 p.m.; voters who still have one can surrender it at their polling place and vote there. The Senate has two voting days left, Nov. 17 and 18, before the session ends Nov. 30 and both bills die. In 2027, the debate starts over with new bill numbers.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime