Two of the last four uncalled House races now have concessions. If every lead holds, Democrats will have 114 of 203 seats
Rep. Brandon Dukes conceded in Butler County and Rep. Shelby Labs posted a farewell in Bucks. Montgomery County's 147th and Lancaster County's 41st have no concession. Counties finish counting today.
A week after Election Day, the Associated Press still had not called four Pennsylvania House races as of the latest reports we found. Two of them now have a concession or its equivalent from the trailing incumbent. All results below are unofficial, with the source and time of each figure.
Why it matters: the size of the Democratic majority sets how many of their own votes leaders can lose on a bill. This session, with 103 Democrats, the House passed some bills with exactly the 102 votes the constitution requires.
The seat count
The AP had called 111 races for Democrats, and Democratic candidates had declared victory in two more competitive races, the 143rd and 147th, which "would give the party 113 seats in the 203-member chamber," Spotlight PA reported Saturday. Those two races and the 41st were not called by the AP as of that report.
Here is where the arithmetic leads if every current leader wins: Democrats 114, Republicans 89. If Republican Rep. Brett Miller overtakes Democrat Brad Chambers in the 41st, it would be 113-90. Under Article III, Section 4 of the state constitution, a bill needs 102 votes, a majority of members elected. At 114, Democrats could lose 12 of their own votes and still pass a bill.
The four races
12th District (Butler County). Democratic Rep. Brandon Dukes conceded to Republican Scott Timko on Wednesday morning, Nov. 4, in a Facebook post, WTAE reported. "This campaign may be over, but my commitment to our community is not," Dukes wrote. Timko led by 575 votes with 99% counted, WTAE reported; the race had not been officially called. Dukes won the seat in an August special election with 50.2% of the vote.
143rd District (Bucks County). Democrat Tim Hayes had 16,597 votes, Republican Rep. Shelby Labs 16,388 and independent Chris Gambino 713, Patch reported at 2:13 a.m. Monday, Nov. 9. That is a 209-vote margin. Labs posted a farewell on Facebook: "Even though the results of this particular election didn't turn out in our favor, I'm no less proud of the work that we've done," she wrote, according to Patch. Hayes called the result "truly an honor."
147th District (Montgomery County). Democrat Margaret Burke had 15,904 votes to Republican Rep. Donna Scheuren's 15,687, a 217-vote margin, Patch reported. Montgomery County's communications director told Spotlight PA on Friday there were up to 230 outstanding ballots that could affect the race. Scheuren had not conceded or responded to requests for comment as of Friday afternoon, Spotlight reported. We found no later statement from her.
41st District (Lancaster County). Chambers leads Miller by 30 votes after provisional ballots were counted Friday. Seven challenged ballots go to a county hearing Thursday. Our separate article has the details.
Advertisement
The AP typically calls a race before certification only when the trailing candidate has no path to victory, Spotlight noted.
How counting ends
Counties must finish counting provisional, military and overseas ballots by Tuesday, Nov. 10, WITF reported. Then come two audits before certification:
- A sample audit required by state law: each county reviews 2% of ballots or 2,000 ballots, whichever is fewer.
- A risk-limiting audit: a hand count of randomly chosen ballot batches in randomly chosen counties for one statewide race. This year that is the governor's race, the only contested statewide office. The Department of State plans to livestream the roll of 10-sided dice that sets the random selection, WITF reported.
Results are scheduled to be certified by Nov. 23 if no litigation intervenes. In a district race, a recount requires petitions from voters; there is no automatic recount, as our explainer describes.
Who's leaving
Every member, winner or loser, keeps voting through Nov. 30. Dukes, Labs, Scheuren and Miller were all recorded present when the House met Monday (roll call 1619). The new House, with members whose terms begin Dec. 1, convenes Jan. 5. Our Nov. 4 results article and our suburban flips article list the other seats that changed hands.