On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

Data centersLocal government

Judge hears neighbors' bid to pause the $15 billion PAX-1 data center in Cumberland County. A Senate bill on local input is up Tuesday

Residents argue Middlesex Township's data center overlay was spot zoning; the developer says the challenge came too late. No ruling yet. Under state law, siting stays a township decision, and the bills that would change that are running out of time.

A Cumberland County judge heard arguments Friday on whether to halt construction of PAX-1, a planned $15 billion data center campus in Middlesex Township, and did not rule from the bench, WITF reported.

Why it matters: the state Department of Environmental Protection is tracking about 70 data center proposals, WITF has reported (our article), and PAX-1 shows how these fights play out under current state law: in township meetings and county courtrooms, not in Harrisburg.

The case

PAX-1 would include 16 data center buildings on 693 acres, WITF reported. Township supervisors created a data center overlay district in May 2025 and gave final approval to the project's first phase in September; votes on the next two phases are planned for February. Construction has started.

A group of residents called Stop PAX-1 filed three legal challenges. Friday's hearing dealt with a zoning challenge from neighboring property owners. Their attorney, Nathan Wolf, argued the overlay treated the site differently from the farms and homes around it and asked the court to pause work on approved phases and stop future approvals. "The idea that you are going to have a permitted use in an area that is surrounded by farms and houses, it's just inconsistent," he told reporters.

The developer, Pennsylvania Data Center Partners, moved to dismiss and argued the request for a stay was filed too late. Its website says the project will create 500 permanent jobs and is designed to protect nearby Conodoguinet Creek. In an earlier hearing, township attorneys said the developer met all legal requirements, WGAL reported.

What state law does, and what's pending

Pennsylvania's Municipalities Planning Code leaves zoning to townships and boroughs. The bills that would give the state or the public a larger role haven't become law:

  • Senate Bill 1408, from Sen. Tracy Pennycuick, a Montgomery County Republican, is on the Senate's Nov. 17 calendar for third consideration. Its title covers "data center transparency," bans certain nondisclosure agreements between public agencies and data centers, and provides "for data centers and public input." If the Senate passes it, it would still need House votes, and the House has no voting days scheduled before the session ends Nov. 30 (our weekend check).
  • House Bill 1834, which would have the Public Utility Commission regulate large data centers, passed the House 104-95 and has sat in a Senate committee since March (our article).

Pennycuick lost her seat Nov. 3. Former DEP Secretary David Hess told WESA that the four Republican senators who lost all had data center projects in their districts. Democrats have said energy costs will be a priority but haven't released bills for 2027.

The judge's ruling on the stay request is pending. We'll update when it comes.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime