Grid watchdog says data centers could add $5 billion to $10 billion more to power bills after December's capacity auction
PJM's independent market monitor says the regional grid operator still hasn't made data centers pay their own way, and it wants the auction delayed. Pennsylvania's data center bills mostly die Nov. 30.
The independent monitor of the regional electricity market that serves Pennsylvania warned Thursday that customers could pay another $5 billion to $10 billion in data center costs after PJM Interconnection's next capacity auction in December, the Pennsylvania Capital-Star reported.
Why it matters: capacity charges make up about one-fifth of the wholesale cost of electricity, and they flow into the supply portion of Pennsylvania utility bills. The next Democratic majorities have named energy costs among their first issues.
What the monitor found
Monitoring Analytics, PJM's independent market monitor, released its State of the Market report for the first nine months of 2026. According to the Capital-Star's account, as republished by WITF:
- The energy market, for power actually used, was competitive.
- The capacity market, which pays power plants to be available at peak demand, was not, mainly because forecasts still count demand from data centers, many of them not yet built.
- Capacity costs rose more than 80% in the first nine months of 2026 compared with the same period in 2025.
- The December auction, for the 2029-30 delivery year, is expected to clear at the maximum price again.
"PJM has failed to implement the broad public policy mandate reflected in the principles agreed to by all the PJM governors and the White House, as well as the Ratepayer Protection Pledge, to ensure that data centers pay their own costs," the monitor said. It recommended postponing the auction until a separate "reliability backstop" auction, which would match data center owners with power suppliers, can be held.
PJM disagrees. Spokesman Jeffrey Shields told the Capital-Star that how data center costs are shared is up to state utility regulators, and that PJM's proposals give states "clear pathways" to assign those costs to large customers. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission rejected PJM's backstop auction plan and much of its proposed rules for large new loads; PJM has filed amended versions.
Pennsylvania's role
PJM runs the grid and wholesale markets for 13 states and Washington, D.C. Gov. Josh Shapiro sued PJM after a record 2024 auction and reached a settlement that capped capacity prices, initially at $325 per megawatt-day. Later auctions have cleared at the cap, the Capital-Star reported.
Shields's point puts some of the work in Harrisburg: the Public Utility Commission sets how Pennsylvania utilities spread costs among customers, and the legislature can change the rules the PUC follows.
Where the state's data center bills stand
Most of the data center bills the House passed this session never got a Senate vote (our roundup). Two examples:
Advertisement
- A fee on data centers to fund household electric rebates (our article).
- HB 1834, which would regulate commercial data centers, require contract filings with the PUC and set clean energy, backup generation and curtailment standards. It passed the House 104-95 in March and has sat in the Senate Consumer Protection Committee since March 31 (our article).
On the Senate side, Sen. Tracy Pennycuick's SB 1408, on data center transparency and nondisclosure agreements with public agencies, is listed for third consideration on Nov. 17. Even if it passes, it would need three House session days, and the House has one left, now listed as non-voting (our article). All of these bills die Nov. 30 unless they become law first, and would have to be reintroduced in 2027.
What's next
- December: PJM's capacity auction for 2029-30, unless it is postponed.
- Jan. 5: the new legislature is sworn in. Rep. Elizabeth Fiedler, a Philadelphia Democrat, argued in a PennLive op-ed this week that lowering energy bills should be a priority for the trifecta.
"We are continuing to get closer and closer to a reliability crisis and an affordability crisis but the solutions are coming forth too slowly," Jon Gordon of Advanced Energy United, a renewable energy industry group, told the Capital-Star.