Two police rules from 2020 laws are moving. A hiring-database rule is up Dec. 3; regulators questioned a PTSD rule
Act 57 of 2020 created a statewide record of why officers leave departments, and Act 59 covered PTSD evaluations for officers. Both have run on temporary rules since 2021.
The state's municipal police training commission is trying to make permanent the rules behind two 2020 police laws, and both are before the Independent Regulatory Review Commission. The final rule on police background investigations and the statewide separation-record database is on the IRRC's Dec. 3 agenda. A proposed rule on PTSD evaluations for officers drew IRRC comments, published in Saturday's Pennsylvania Bulletin, that it hasn't answered yet.
Why it matters: the background law exists so that an officer who leaves one department under a cloud can't quietly be hired by another. According to the commission's regulatory analysis, as of July about 1,200 law enforcement agencies were subject to it and more than 41,000 officers were in the database.
The background investigation rule
The Municipal Police Officers' Education and Training Commission's final rule (IRRC No. 3459) carries out Act 57 of 2020, codified at 44 Pa.C.S. Chapter 73. It replaces temporary rules from March 2021 that the analysis says have expired. According to the analysis, the rule:
- sets minimum background investigation standards for hiring officers;
- requires departments to send the commission information on every officer who leaves, and to query the database before hiring;
- requires prior employers to release employment information when a hiring agency asks; and
- lets an officer dispute a separation record and have it corrected, or file a statement of disagreement.
The commission received two comments when the proposal was published in October 2025, the analysis says. One came from a private citizen and the other from a law school policing project. Some departments told staff they were concerned about the cost of steps the law now requires, such as credit checks.
The analysis says Pennsylvania is "one of the first states" to require separation records. It also notes that 143 Pennsylvania agencies take part in a national database of officers whose certifications were revoked.
The PTSD rule
The other rule (IRRC No. 3495) carries out Act 59 of 2020, which requires law enforcement agencies to provide officers with a mental health evaluation for post-traumatic stress disorder. IRRC issued comments Nov. 4 on the proposed version, published in September:
- Reporting diagnoses. The proposal requires agencies to notify the commission when an evaluation results in a PTSD diagnosis, but says the notice can't include information about the diagnosis. A law firm commenter called the two subsections "somewhat contradictory." The Fraternal Order of Police's state lodge asked that the notice requirement be removed, arguing that broad disclosure of diagnoses goes beyond what the law allows. IRRC asked the commission to explain why the requirement is needed and reasonable.
- Evaluation or treatment. The law and the earlier temporary rules mention treatment, but the proposal's scope covers only evaluation. IRRC asked why.
- Who can evaluate. The Pennsylvania Medical Society objected to requiring psychiatrists to be board certified, and the Pennsylvania Psychiatric Society objected to counting nurse practitioners and physician assistants as "licensed physicians." IRRC asked the commission to review both definitions.
The commission has to respond to the comments in its final version and has two years from the end of the comment period, Oct. 5, 2026, to submit it, or the proposal is deemed withdrawn.
What's next
The IRRC meets at 10 a.m. Dec. 3 at 555 Walnut St. in Harrisburg. It asks speakers to register in advance and send written remarks to irrc@irrc.state.pa.us; remarks are limited to three minutes. The same agenda includes the Public Utility Commission's procedure rules, supervision rules for associate marriage and family therapists and counselors, and appraiser fees. Last week the commission approved all eight rules it voted on (our report).