The State Board of Education is set to vote on new PSSA and Keystone cut scores. 'Proficient' stays at 1,000; 'advanced' gets easier to reach
The change would apply to tests students took last spring, whose results the state has held back. Philadelphia moved its school selection deadline to Dec. 16 while it waits.
The State Board of Education is scheduled to vote Thursday, Nov. 19, at its regular meeting in Harrisburg on new cut scores for the state's math and reading tests: the PSSA, taken in elementary and middle school, and the high school Keystone exams. The proposal from the Department of Education keeps the score needed to be "proficient" at 1,000 but lowers the score needed to be "advanced" in nearly every grade, Chalkbeat Philadelphia reported.
Why it matters: the change would apply to tests students took in spring 2026, whose results the state has held back pending the vote. In Philadelphia, families need the scores to apply to some magnet schools. It would be the first change to these cut scores since they were set in 2015.
What would change
From Chalkbeat's report on the department's presentation to the board:
- Proficient: the cutoff stays at 1,000.
- Advanced: the minimum score drops in nearly all grades, so more students would be rated advanced.
- Below basic: "mixed impacts," depending on grade and subject.
- The share of students rated proficient would "remain statistically consistent with historical expectations," the department said.
Nearly 90 Pennsylvania educators worked with the department on the review. Brian Campbell, who directs the department's bureau of curriculum, assessment and instruction, said the thresholds were overdue for an update and would create "a new baseline." New math and reading standards are "years away," he said, so new cut scores are recommended in the meantime. The state changed science cut scores earlier this year.
Changing the scale will make it harder to compare this year's results with earlier years.
Last year's results
On the current scale, 50.7% of elementary students scored basic or below basic in reading in 2025 and 12.5% scored advanced; in math, 58.3% scored basic or below and 16.6% advanced, WTAJ reported.
The objections
"Pennsylvanians should be highly suspect of the proposed test score changes," said Rachel Langan, a senior education policy analyst at the Commonwealth Foundation, according to WTAJ. Mark Gleason, writing in The Philadelphia Citizen, urged Gov. Josh Shapiro not to "lower standards."
The Philadelphia delay
The Philadelphia School District pushed its school selection deadline back about three weeks, to Dec. 16, the second delay this year, because families need test scores to apply to some magnet schools, Chalkbeat reported. District officials said the state put this year's scores "on hold." The district expects to close its school selection website from Nov. 24 to Dec. 2 to load the scores.
What happens next
If the board adopts the new cut scores, the department will share school-level results with districts in the following days, and statewide results are expected in "early 2027," Education Secretary Carrie Rowe said, according to Chalkbeat. The board's meeting calendar lists the meeting at 333 Market Street in Harrisburg.