A REAL ID bill passed the House 203-0 in April 2025. It is on the Senate calendar again, 567 days later
House Bill 238 would write into law the documents PennDOT accepts as proof of a Social Security number, from W-2s to pay stubs. It was tabled three times along the way. One Senate vote would send it to Shapiro.
A two-paragraph REAL ID bill that passed the House without a single no vote is back on the Senate's Nov. 17 calendar, 567 days after the House sent it over. House Bill 238 hasn't been amended in the Senate, so a Senate vote would send it to Gov. Josh Shapiro.
Why it matters: it shows how a bill with no recorded opposition can still run out the clock. And it would put into law a rule PennDOT now follows only as policy.
What the bill says
The entire bill, Printer's No. 190, adds one section to the Vehicle Code. To verify a REAL ID applicant's Social Security number, PennDOT "shall accept" any of these, as long as it meets federal REAL ID rules:
- a Social Security card;
- a W-2 form;
- an SSA-1099 form;
- a non-SSA-1099 form; or
- a pay stub.
It takes effect immediately.
PennDOT already does this
PennDOT expanded its list in June 2023 to accept the same four alternatives to a Social Security card, WVIA reported at the time. A pay stub must show the applicant's name and full nine-digit number. The department's REAL ID document page still lists those options.
That change was administrative, so a future administration could reverse it. HB 238 would make it state law. The bill's memo notes it is a reintroduction of HB 1243 from the 2023-24 session.
Federal enforcement began May 7, 2025. Since then, travelers need a REAL ID, a passport or another federally accepted ID to board domestic flights and enter some federal buildings.
567 days
From the bill's official history:
Advertisement
- Jan. 22, 2025: introduced by Rep. Kerry Benninghoff (R-Centre/Mifflin) with 15 co-sponsors from both parties, including Rep. Ed Neilson (D-Philadelphia), chair of the House Transportation Committee.
- April 24, 2025: passed the House 203-0.
- June 4, 2025: reported by Senate Transportation.
- June 9-10, 2025: second consideration, then re-referred to and reported from Appropriations. It has been eligible for a final Senate vote since.
- Sept. 2025 to Feb. 2026: laid on the table three times and removed twice. The last tabling, Feb. 3, is marked "Pursuant to Senate Rule 9."
- Sept. 30, 2026: removed from the table again.
We found no public explanation from Senate leaders for the wait.
On the same calendar
HB 238 is one of four unamended House bills that could go to Shapiro with a single Senate vote. The others are HB 2614, which phases DEHP out of IV bags; HB 593, Neilson's bill to speed junk titles for abandoned vehicles (passed 202-0); and HB 348, Rep. Tim Bonner's medical assistance notice bill (passed 199-0). Our calendar article has the full list.
If it isn't passed by Nov. 30, it dies, and Benninghoff, a former House Republican leader, would have to reintroduce it in the new session.