Republicans take stock: House leader Topper says the party must 'pick a direction.' Senate Republicans still haven't named a minority team
Two weeks after losing the Senate, the caucus that has run it for decades returns Tuesday for its last two days in the majority. Its 2027-28 leaders haven't been announced.
Pennsylvania Republicans had their worst election in at least 50 years on Nov. 3, the Pennsylvania Capital-Star's Peter Hall wrote in a story published Monday. Gov. Josh Shapiro won a second term, Democrats added to their House majority, and they took the state Senate, which Republicans had controlled almost continuously since 1978. Four Republican members of Congress from Pennsylvania lost.
Why it matters: Republicans will be in the minority in both chambers in January for the first time in decades. Who leads them decides who negotiates with Shapiro and the new Democratic majorities on the budget and anything that needs bipartisan votes.
What Republicans told the Capital-Star
- House Minority Leader Jesse Topper of Bedford County, re-elected leader last week (our article): voters "spoke loud and clear that they're unhappy with Republicans." He said the first order of business is "to pick a direction," and asked whether the party stands for free trade or tariffs: "Right now, we're trying to do a little bit of both, and I just don't believe that works."
- Former House Majority Leader Kerry Benninghoff of Centre County, who won re-election, said rising prices were the main source of voters' frustration.
- Former U.S. Rep. Charlie Dent, who served 14 years in the General Assembly, called the election "a referendum on the president" and warned Democrats to "govern accordingly, carefully."
- Charlie Gerow, a 2022 candidate for the GOP nomination for governor, said the party needs "real campaigns run by real people, the old-fashioned way."
- Dennis Roddy, a former aide to Gov. Tom Corbett who said he's no longer a party member, said nominee Stacy Garrity "was without funds." She raised $9.2 million through mid-October; Shapiro's campaign spent $66.3 million, the Capital-Star reported (our results article).
State Republican Party Chair Greg Rothman, who is also a state senator from Cumberland County, declined an interview. A party spokesman said Garrity "worked as hard, if not harder, than any candidate across the country" and that the party will analyze the results.
The Senate caucus hasn't said who leads it next
Senate Democrats named their 2027-28 team Nov. 12: Maria Collett for majority leader and Jay Costa for president pro tempore (our article). As of Monday, the Senate Republicans' news page had no leadership announcement; its newest release was dated Oct. 30.
The current Republican leaders, according to the Senate's officers page, include President Pro Tempore Kim Ward and Majority Leader Joe Pittman. Ward and Pittman will still run the floor Tuesday and Wednesday. The pro tem in particular changes hands: the new Senate elects one when it organizes Jan. 5.
Four Republican senators lost: Frank Farry, Jarrett Coleman, Tracy Pennycuick and Rosemary Brown. Republicans picked up the 36th District in Lancaster County, which left Democrats with 26 of 50 seats (our article).
What a 24-seat minority can still do
Bills need 26 votes to pass the Senate, so a united Democratic caucus doesn't need Republican votes for most legislation. Some things still need them:
- State-related university funding, for Penn State, Pitt, Temple and Lincoln, needs two-thirds of each chamber, 34 votes in the Senate.
- Some confirmations need two-thirds of the Senate, including members of the Liquor Control Board.
The outgoing Senate's last scheduled voting days are Tuesday and Wednesday (our guide).