On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State SenateBill guide

One Senate vote would let the Turnpike share toll data on vehicles named in Amber Alerts. The House narrowed the bill first

SB 1273 adds an exception to the privacy rule for E-ZPass and toll-by-plate records. The House limited it to 'vehicle movement information' that is 'reasonably tailored' to finding an abducted child or an endangered missing person.

The second concurrence vote on the Senate's Nov. 17 calendar is Senate Bill 1273, from Sen. Camera Bartolotta, a Washington County Republican. It would let the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission give police records of where a vehicle has traveled on the Turnpike when that vehicle has been named in an Amber Alert or a missing endangered person alert.

Why it matters: state law treats electronic toll records as private. The bill adds an exception, and the wording of that exception decides how much travel data police can get and when. If the Senate agrees to the House's version, the bill goes to Gov. Josh Shapiro.

What the law says now

Section 8117 of Title 74 covers electronic toll collection, the system behind E-ZPass and toll-by-plate billing. According to the House Appropriations Committee's fiscal note, the bill would "create a fourth exception to the rule that electronic toll collection information is to be kept private by the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission."

Bartolotta's co-sponsorship memo said the bill would "reaffirm and clarify" that the Turnpike can share vehicle information in these cases, to "ensure that our law enforcement has as many tools as possible to assist in the recovery of abducted children." It didn't cite a specific case.

The two versions

The Senate's version (PN 1610) said the privacy rule wouldn't prevent giving "information to law enforcement officials for the purpose of assisting in the recovery of abducted children and missing persons who are at a special risk of harm or injury" identified through the state's Amber Alert or Missing Endangered Person Advisory System.

The House's version (PN 2003) is narrower. It allows "vehicle movement information" only "for a vehicle that has been identified in an alert" through those systems, and only if the information is "reasonably tailored and provided solely for the purpose" of finding the child or missing person. The House Judiciary Committee adopted the change 26-0 on Oct. 5.

Both versions would take effect 60 days after signing. Neither would make toll records public.

The votes

  • Senate final passage, June 24: 48-2 (roll call). Republicans Scott Hutchinson and Dawn Keefer voted no.
  • House final passage, Oct. 20: 202-1 (roll call). Rep. Bud Cook, a Washington County Republican, voted no.
  • Senate Rules Committee, Oct. 21: 17-0 to send the bill to the floor for a concurrence vote (committee vote).

The bill's five co-sponsors include Democrat John Kane and four Republicans: Rosemary Brown, Elder Vogel, Pat Stefano and Joe Picozzi.

What happens next

A Senate vote to concur Tuesday or Wednesday would finish the bill. Once the speaker signs it, which a non-voting House session Nov. 19 can provide, it goes to Shapiro, who would have 10 days to act while the legislature is in session. If the Senate doesn't vote, the bill dies Nov. 30.

Our Sunday check explains how to follow the Senate's votes.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime