On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

Criminal justiceLame duck

Eight months after the Supreme Court struck down automatic life sentences for felony murder, the replacement law dies with the session

The House and Senate each passed a version and amended each other's. HB 1042 has sat in the Senate Rules Committee since Sept. 28, and the Senate ended its term Nov. 17. Judges keep sentencing without a statute.

The General Assembly will end its 2025-26 session Nov. 30 without replacing the sentencing law for second-degree murder that the state Supreme Court struck down in March. The two bills that got furthest, HB 1042 and SB 1400, are each stuck in the other chamber, and the Senate held its last voting day Nov. 17 (our report).

Why it matters: second-degree murder is often called felony murder. Until the ruling, a conviction meant an automatic life sentence without parole. Nearly 1,100 people are serving those sentences, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported. With no new statute, judges are deciding sentences case by case, without statewide guidelines.

The ruling

In Commonwealth v. Lee, decided March 26, the Supreme Court held that mandatory life without parole for second-degree murder is unconstitutional. It didn't ban life sentences: judges may still impose one after weighing a defendant's role. The court stayed its ruling for 120 days so lawmakers could write a new law, a deadline that passed July 24, Spotlight PA reported. The court later turned down district attorneys' request for more time. It didn't decide whether the ruling applies to people already serving life, leaving that to the legislature.

How the two bills moved

  • HB 1042, from Rep. Napoleon Nelson, passed the House 149-50 on March 23. The Senate rewrote it and passed it 30-20 on July 12. On July 23, the House agreed to the Senate's changes with its own amendments, 102-100, sending it back. The Senate referred it to its Rules and Executive Nominations Committee on Sept. 28. There has been no action since.
  • SB 1400, from Sen. Lisa Baker, passed the Senate 30-20 on June 25 and went to the House Judiciary Committee the next day. It hasn't moved.

Where the chambers differ

According to the Inquirer's summary of the two positions in August:

  • The Senate's approach sets a 35-year mandatory minimum for most second-degree murder convictions and keeps life without parole as an option. People already serving life would become eligible for parole after 35 years, or after 20 years if they are at least 70.
  • The House's approach sets no mandatory minimum. It directs the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing to write guidelines and keeps life without parole available. People already serving life would become parole-eligible after 30 years, and it adds medical parole for the terminally ill.

Sen. Frank Farry said under the Senate's plan a judge could impose 10 to 40 years in cases of lesser culpability, North Penn Now reported in July. Attorney General Dave Sunday said then that "inaction is not an option." The Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association and the Fraternal Order of Police supported the Senate bill.

What happens without a law

The ruling made one person, Derek Lee, eligible for resentencing, and he could still receive life, the Inquirer reported. Others must petition the courts. Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner called mandatory sentencing "a terrible idea"; Luzerne County District Attorney Sam Sanguedolce said he couldn't "properly advise the defendant what the consequence might be." Philadelphia's chief public defender estimated resentencing would cost about $40,000 per defendant.

What comes next

  • Nov. 30: HB 1042 and SB 1400 die.
  • January 2027: a new legislature, with Democrats controlling both chambers and the governor's office, can start over with new bills.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime