On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State SenateLeadership

Who will run the new Democratic Senate? Costa is in line for president pro tempore. The other top jobs haven't been claimed

The full Senate elects its president pro tempore; only Democratic senators choose the majority leader and Appropriations chair. In 2022, both caucuses picked leaders a week after Election Day.

Democrats won a 26-24 majority in the Pennsylvania Senate on Tuesday, by AP race calls, and now have to decide who leads it. Senate Democratic Leader Jay Costa of Allegheny County appears likely to become president pro tempore, the chamber's top officer, Spotlight PA reported Wednesday. Gov. Josh Shapiro, House Speaker Joanna McClinton, House Majority Leader Matt Bradford and Sen. Vincent Hughes all referred to Costa by that title, according to Spotlight.

Why it matters: the Senate's leaders decide which bills come up for votes and when, and they negotiate the state budget with the governor and House. This session, many House-passed bills stopped in Senate committees.

Which jobs, and who picks

  • President pro tempore: elected by the full Senate, by a simple majority, Spotlight reported. The vote could come "as early as November," according to Spotlight.
  • Majority leader and Appropriations chair: chosen by Democratic senators only. No one would discuss who plans to run, Spotlight reported.

Hughes, of Philadelphia, has been the Democrats' ranking member on Appropriations since 2010, the Inquirer reported. He would not say whether he will run for majority leader, telling Spotlight he has "really enjoyed" the Appropriations role and hopes members keep him there.

What the records add

The constitution sets two pro tem elections. Article II, Section 9 of the state constitution says the Senate elects a president pro tempore "at the beginning and close of each regular session." The current session closes Nov. 30. The new one begins Jan. 5, 2027, the first Tuesday in January under Article II, Section 4.

How it went last time. After the 2022 election, Senate Republicans and Democrats each chose their leaders on Nov. 15, a week after Election Day, WESA reported. The Senate then elected Sen. Kim Ward interim president pro tempore, to serve from Dec. 1 to Jan. 2, and scheduled the vote for the full session for Jan. 3, Levittown Now reported. That year Republicans held the majority before and after the election. This time, the Republican majority stays in place through Nov. 30 while the incoming majority is Democratic. Neither caucus has announced how it will handle the interim period.

The current Democratic team. Costa has led the caucus since 2011. In 2022, Democrats chose Costa as leader, Sen. Christine Tartaglione of Philadelphia as whip and Hughes as Appropriations chair, Levittown Now reported. The caucus's leadership page lists Costa as leader, Tartaglione as whip and Sen. Maria Collett as caucus chair.

The current Republican team. Ward, of Westmoreland County, is president pro tempore and Sen. Joe Pittman of Indiana County is majority leader. Ward was reelected pro tem unanimously in January, with votes from both parties, WPXI reported. In an interview WPXI published on election night, Ward said the post is "not a very, very partisan position" and that if control changed, "I'm hoping that if that happens, the Democrats also work with us across the aisle." A spokesperson for Pittman did not respond to Spotlight's requests for comment about the results or his leadership.

The margin. Under Article III, Section 4 of the constitution, a bill needs a majority of members elected, 26 of 50, to pass. With 26 Democrats, the majority can pass bills on its own only if every Democrat votes yes. Sen. Lisa Boscola of Northampton County told Spotlight she could support a $15 minimum wage but not $20, an example of the range within the caucus. Spotlight reported that Senate Democratic leaders will have to keep their members together with a very small majority.

What happens next

The outgoing Senate's last scheduled voting days are Nov. 17 and 18, according to the Senate calendar. New senators' terms begin Dec. 1. The new Senate convenes Jan. 5 and elects its president pro tempore for the 2027-28 session. Our article on the Senate results lists the districts that changed hands, and our look at committee chairs shows what the new majority inherits.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime