On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State SenateNominations

The Senate's Nov. 17 nominations calendar lists 189 nominations. Most are placeholders, including for state police commissioner

Governors keep vacancies on hold by nominating stand-ins who never take office, to meet a 90-day constitutional deadline. With Democrats taking the Senate in January, many of these jobs will be filled by nominees a new majority confirms.

The Senate's executive nominations calendar for Tuesday, Nov. 17, runs 10 pages and lists 189 nominations: state boards, hospital trustees, county row offices, judges and several top state jobs. A close look shows that most of the slots carry the same handful of names over and over, each listed as living in Harrisburg, Mechanicsburg or Camp Hill.

That is a long-standing practice known as placeholder nominations. Why it matters: the jobs behind those names include the commissioner of the Pennsylvania State Police, the state's Victim Advocate and the secretary of General Services, and who actually fills them will be decided after Democrats take control of the Senate in January.

Why placeholders exist

The state constitution (Article IV, Section 8) says the governor must nominate someone to fill a vacancy "within 90 days of the first day of the vacancy and not thereafter." The Senate then has 25 legislative days to act. If it doesn't, "the nominee shall take office as if the appointment had been consented to by the Senate."

When a governor isn't ready to name a real candidate within 90 days, the office submits a stand-in to keep the appointment power. Spotlight PA described the practice in 2021, reporting that placeholders "are just names on paper and are never intended to fill those positions." The nominations are later withdrawn and replaced. We are not naming the stand-ins, who are not candidates for these jobs.

What the calendar shows

On the Nov. 17 calendar, which we counted line by line:

  • 189 entries, a few names. Five names account for about 150 of the entries. One appears 36 times, on posts ranging from the State Board of Barber Examiners to the Allegheny County controller's office. Most entries were referred to the Senate on Sept. 28, 2026.
  • State Police commissioner. The nomination "vice, Christopher Paris, resigned" carries a placeholder name. Paris left in January to take a job with the FBI, and Shapiro named Lt. Col. George Bivens acting commissioner, according to the governor's office. Bivens would need Senate confirmation to drop the "acting" title.
  • Other top posts. Placeholder names also sit in the slots for Victim Advocate (vice Suzanne Estrella), secretary of General Services (vice Reginald McNeil) and commissioner of Professional and Occupational Affairs (vice Kalonji Johnson).
  • Judges. Common Pleas judgeships in Allegheny, Berks, Erie, Lancaster, Lehigh, Philadelphia, Washington and other counties are listed, each marked "Two-thirds vote required." Most carry placeholder names.
  • A few names appear only once or twice, including the nominee listed for Physician General, the state's top doctor, to replace Dr. Denise Johnson. We found no announcement from the governor's office for these nominations, so we can't say which of them are intended appointees.

The calendar lists each nomination's referral date and a running count of legislative days. Most entries show 10 legislative days, well short of the 25-day limit; a few referred in June show 19.

What happens next

The calendar doesn't mean the Senate will vote on any of these Tuesday. Nominations go through the Senate Rules and Executive Nominations Committee, now chaired by Majority Leader Joe Pittman, a Republican. In January, Democrats will control that committee and the floor, with Maria Collett as their pick for majority leader (our article). We found no public statement from the governor's office or Senate leaders on which nominations, if any, will move before Nov. 30.

The Senate also confirms members of boards that will matter to the new majority's agenda, such as the Public Utility Commission. Our weekend schedule check has the rest of the week.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime