At a Lancaster County farm roundtable, Shapiro criticized local police deals with ICE. Bills on both sides of that question never left House Judiciary
More than 30 farm businesses and groups asked federal officials to change enforcement tactics and visa rules. Pennsylvania now has 146 local agencies with 287(g) agreements, up from 78 in April. State bills to ban or require cooperation die Nov. 30.
Gov. Josh Shapiro and Agriculture Secretary Russell Redding met with farm and food-industry leaders in Lancaster County on Thursday, Nov. 19, to hear how federal immigration enforcement is affecting their workers, WITF and the Pennsylvania Capital-Star reported.
Why it matters: immigration law is federal, but how much state and local police help enforce it is partly a state and local choice. Shapiro used the roundtable to criticize agreements that let local officers work with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Bills that would have banned those agreements, or required more cooperation, sat in the House Judiciary Committee all session.
What the farm groups asked for
More than 30 Pennsylvania farmers, agriculture businesses and organizations endorsed a letter to U.S. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, the Capital-Star reported. Christian Herr, president of PennAg Industries Association, wrote it. "We are concerned that employees with legal status have been detained in recent actions and aggressive enforcement has caused workers with status to miss work due to fears of being caught in farm-targeted actions," it says. The letter also expresses support for a secure border.
The groups asked federal agents to focus on criminals rather than workers, and backed the Securing Agriculture's Workforce Act from U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson, which would let H-2A visa holders stay year-round and open the program to more agriculture-related businesses.
At the roundtable:
- Sarah Zost, president of the State Horticultural Association of Pennsylvania and an Adams County fruit grower, said ICE agents detained three of her workers in a commuting traffic stop, a quarter of her winter crew. "Being here legally does not get you a get-out-of-jail-free card for harassment from ICE," she said.
- A Lancaster County poultry company executive said 17 of the company's workers were detained this year, including some with work permits, and some were taken as far as Oklahoma.
- Herr said many people in agriculture, including some who voted for President Donald Trump, are uncomfortable with how the mass deportation program has played out.
What Shapiro and Redding said
Shapiro said Pennsylvania State Police don't work with ICE and don't ask people for their papers, WITF reported. Of 287(g) agreements, which let local police assist ICE, he said: "That is something that I think is not helpful. That undermines the most important tool that I think law enforcement has, which is trust." He said many of the changes the groups want would have to come from Washington.
"A workforce on ICE is not a solution for agriculture in this country," Redding said.
The agreements
Pennsylvania had 146 local agencies with formal 287(g) agreements as of early November, up from 78 in April, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported. All but three use the task force model, the broadest of the program's three types. A Homeland Security spokesperson told the Inquirer the state had none under the Biden administration.
Advertisement
County decisions vary. In Dauphin County, a proposed policy to stop coordinating with ICE on detainees with immigration holds tied 3-3 at the prison board Wednesday, so the county will keep cooperating, WITF reported.
The state bills
Each of these was referred to the House Judiciary Committee and never got a committee vote:
- HB 1872, from Rep. Abigail Salisbury, an Allegheny County Democrat, would bar the State Police from performing immigration arrests, putting the department's current practice into law. Referred Sept. 22, 2025.
- HB 403, from Rep. Ryan Warner, a Republican, titled "Ending Sanctuary Cities in Pennsylvania" in its sponsor's memo, would provide for immigration "preemption and cooperation" and create an Immigration Cooperation Fund. Referred Jan. 31, 2025.
- HB 1693, from Rep. Craig Williams, a Republican, would allow private lawsuits against public officials who violate federal immigration detainers. Referred July 2, 2025.
All three die when the session ends Nov. 30. Legislators would have to reintroduce them in January.