On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

State SenateEnergy

The Senate's last vote of the term on policy was a 29-19 resolution ordering a study of small oil and gas wells

SR 374 directs the Joint State Government Commission to report within a year on the conventional oil and gas industry's role in meeting rising energy demand. Two Democrats joined every Republican present.

On its last day of the term, the Senate adopted one resolution: Senate Resolution 374, which directs the Joint State Government Commission to study "the strategic importance of this Commonwealth's conventional oil and natural gas industry in resolving the growing demand for energy." The vote Tuesday was 29-19 (roll call 620).

Why it matters: a Senate resolution isn't a law and doesn't spend money directly, but it assigns work to the legislature's research agency. This one asks for a report that the new Democratic majority will receive in 2027.

What "conventional" means

Pennsylvania's oil and gas wells fall into two groups. Unconventional wells are the deep, horizontally drilled and fracked Marcellus and Utica shale wells. Conventional wells are generally shallower, older-style wells, many run by small operators, especially in the northwest and southwest. The two are regulated under different rules.

The resolution, sponsored by Sen. Scott Hutchinson of Venango County with Sen. Cris Dush, says public attention "has largely centered on large-scale unconventional shale development" while conventional wells "continue to produce reliable domestic energy, support rural electric and gas infrastructure" and supply "specialty Pennsylvania grade crude oil" for refining. It points to rising electricity use from "cloud computing infrastructure" and manufacturing.

What the study must cover

The text lists nine topics, including:

  • the industry's current and projected economic contribution;
  • its role in future electricity generation;
  • "the impact of statutory and regulatory policy on small conventional operators";
  • differences between conventional and unconventional operations;
  • "rural workforce and economic implications associated with oil and natural gas industry decline"; and
  • the role of conventional infrastructure in energy reliability planning.

The commission must report its findings and recommendations to the General Assembly within 12 months of adoption, or by about Nov. 17, 2027.

The resolution doesn't mention orphaned or abandoned wells, plugging costs or environmental violations, issues that have drawn attention to the conventional industry in recent years.

The vote

All 27 Republicans voted yes. Democrats Lisa Boscola of Northampton County and Marty Flynn of Lackawanna County joined them. The 19 no votes were all Democrats, including the party's incoming leaders, Maria Collett, Jay Costa and Vincent Hughes (who leads in 2027). Democrats Patty Kim and Nick Miller didn't vote.

The Environmental Resources and Energy Committee reported the resolution Oct. 21. It was introduced Sept. 24.

The commission

The Joint State Government Commission is the General Assembly's shared research office. It's governed by members of both chambers and both parties and often produces studies on assignment from a resolution. Its reports go to lawmakers; they don't change the law unless a bill follows.

The resolution was the only item of business besides two concurrence votes and the nominations that the Senate took up on its final day (full rundown). Data center bills that drew far more debate this year were left on the calendar (background).

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime