On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

CourtsPublic comment

Anyone filing in a Pennsylvania court may have to certify they checked AI-written citations. Comments on the proposal are due Nov. 24

A Supreme Court advisory committee proposes one statewide rule for lawyers and people representing themselves, replacing local rules some counties already use. Sanctions could include dismissal of a case.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Advisory Committee on Artificial Intelligence wants everyone who files papers in a Pennsylvania court, from big-firm lawyers to people representing themselves, to certify that they checked anything generative AI helped write. The proposal, published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin Oct. 24, is open for public comment until Nov. 24.

Why it matters: AI tools can invent cases and quotes. Spotlight PA reported that filings in at least 13 Pennsylvania court cases in 2025 contained confirmed or implied AI "hallucinations." The rule would apply in every court in the Unified Judicial System, from magisterial district judges to the Supreme Court.

What filers would have to check

Filers who use generative AI would have to confirm that:

  1. every legal authority they cite actually exists;
  2. every quotation appears in the source they name;
  3. any summary of a legal principle is "reasonably supported by the actual text"; and
  4. every stated fact has a basis in the case record.

They would sign a certification, either a separate form or language inside the filing, saying their filing complies. On the courts' PACFile e-filing system, the committee says it would become a checkbox next to the existing certification about confidential information.

Courts and filing offices wouldn't have to check for compliance. But a court could, on a motion or on its own, reprimand a filer, refuse to consider a filing, dismiss a case, order costs and attorneys' fees, or order the filing corrected.

Why one statewide rule

The committee's explanatory report says some judicial districts already have their own rules: two counties require an affidavit disclosing which AI tool was used and which parts it wrote, two require an affidavit that the filer is responsible regardless, and one treats a lawyer's signature as certifying that citations weren't created by AI. The committee recommends that the statewide notice replace those local rules. The report doesn't name the counties.

It cites other states' approaches, including a Florida rule that a signer represents "the legal authorities identified exist and are accurate," and a pending Texas proposal.

The Supreme Court adopted an interim policy in 2025 on AI use by judges and court staff, Spotlight PA reported; it doesn't cover lawyers or the public. The Pennsylvania Bar Association hadn't taken a position, a spokesperson told Spotlight PA.

How to comment

Comments go to the Advisory Committee on Artificial Intelligence by email at AIAC@pacourts.us (preferred), by fax at 717-231-3327, or by mail to the Pennsylvania Judicial Center, P.O. Box 61260, Harrisburg, PA 17106-1260. After Nov. 24, the committee can revise the proposal or send it as is to the seven justices for a vote.

This is a court rule, not a law; the General Assembly has no vote on it. Lawmakers' own AI measure this session, a disclosure requirement for AI-generated campaign ads, takes effect Dec. 21 (our article).

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime