1.1 million mail ballots are back. Those with a missing or wrong date will be set aside, not counted, while the courts decide
State guidance tells counties to segregate undated and misdated mail ballots. The U.S. Supreme Court has had Pennsylvania's own appeal on the date rule since February and hasn't acted.
Pennsylvania voters had returned 1,114,767 mail and absentee ballots as of 8 a.m. today, out of 1,315,879 sent out, Spotlight PA reported, citing Department of State data. That is about 85%, leaving roughly 201,000 ballots still out. Counties began opening and scanning the returned ballots at 7 a.m.
Why it matters: as those envelopes are opened, some won't be counted tonight. Under state guidance issued in September, counties are told to set aside ballots whose return envelope has no date or a date that can't reasonably be the day the voter signed it. Whether those ballots should count is still being fought in two courts.
Who has returned ballots
Of the ballots returned by 8 a.m., 718,641 came from registered Democrats, 280,442 from Republicans and 115,684 from voters in other parties or none, the Inquirer reported from the same state data.
If you still have a mail ballot: it must reach your county election office or an official drop box by 8 p.m. Postmarks don't count, and the state says not to mail it now. You can instead bring the ballot and its return envelope to your polling place, surrender them and vote there. If you can't surrender them, you can vote by provisional ballot, according to the Department of State's mail ballot guidance.
What the records add
What the guidance says. Version 3.4 of the department's guidance, dated Sept. 18, tells county boards at the pre-canvass and canvass to "segregate any ballots enclosed in a declaration envelope that is undated or deemed to have an incorrect date." It draws the line narrowly: a ballot counts as incorrectly dated only if the written date can't reasonably be read as the day the voter completed the declaration. Envelopes dated in the European day-month-year style, or with slashes or other symbols in the date boxes, should not be treated as incorrectly dated and should be counted, it says. Ballots with no signature or no secrecy envelope are set aside separately.
A footnote explains why the guidance says segregate rather than reject: the issue "remains a subject of continued litigation." It cites two cases.
The federal case, waiting at the U.S. Supreme Court. In Eakin v. Adams County Board of Elections, a federal judge ruled in March 2025 that rejecting mail ballots over the handwritten date is unconstitutional, and the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed in August 2025, the guidance notes. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review that ruling, in case No. 25-967. The docket shows:
- Feb. 11, 2026: petition filed.
- March 19: an amicus brief from Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward (R-Westmoreland) and others.
- May 29 to June 2: responses from the voters who brought the case, several county election boards and the national and state Republican parties.
- June 29: the court asked the U.S. solicitor general for the federal government's views.
No decision on whether to take the case is listed. That leaves the 3rd Circuit's ruling standing for now.
Advertisement
The state case. The guidance also cites Baxter v. Philadelphia Board of Elections, pending before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, which asks whether the date rule violates the state constitution. The department "encourages counties to consult with their solicitors" and says it will issue new guidance if needed.
The bill that would settle it. House Bill 1396, from House Speaker Joanna McClinton (D-Philadelphia), would drop the handwritten date requirement. It passed the House 102-101 on May 13, 2025, and has been in the Senate State Government Committee since May 22, 2025, as our Oct. 29 article detailed. A separate bill to let counties process mail ballots before Election Day, House Bill 37, is also waiting in that committee; see our Oct. 31 article.
What happens next
Segregated ballots stay sealed apart while counties finish counting. Each county decides with its solicitor what to do with them, and the number of set-aside ballots could matter in a close race. The state Supreme Court ruled in 2025 that counties must notify voters whose mail ballots will be rejected. If you got such a notice, you can still vote by provisional ballot at your polling place before 8 p.m. Counties must certify results by Nov. 23; our Nov. 1 article lays out the timeline. Questions go to 1-877-VOTESPA (1-877-868-3772) or your county election office.