On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

General AssemblyVoter ID

Both candidates for governor say they're open to voter ID. The House bill has sat in Appropriations for 534 days

House Bill 771 cleared the State Government Committee 14-12 in May 2025, with two Democrats joining every Republican. It was sent to Appropriations and never came back to the floor.

Voter ID is one of the bigger items the General Assembly is leaving unfinished this session, WITF and Spotlight PA reported this week. Pennsylvania voters now have to show identification only the first time they vote at a polling place.

Why it matters: the issue has come up in the governor's race, and whichever party controls the Senate after Nov. 3 will help decide whether ID rules change by law, by constitutional amendment, or not at all.

What has been said

At the Oct. 7 debate, Gov. Josh Shapiro said he was "open to putting a voter ID bill on my desk for my signature" if lawmakers could write one that would not keep legitimate voters from casting ballots, Spotlight PA reported. The WITF/Spotlight report says he wants a bill "based in fact."

Senate Republicans have pushed for a constitutional amendment instead of a bill. An amendment has to pass both chambers in two consecutive sessions and then win a statewide vote. Senate Republicans have also tied a voter ID amendment to the constitutional amendment that would open a lawsuit window for survivors of child sexual abuse, which Shapiro criticized as "tying justice to … pet political projects," according to WITF. Our Oct. 23 article covers that amendment's record.

What the records add

The bill. House Bill 771, from Rep. Tom Mehaffie, a Dauphin County Republican, would require voters to show ID and change rules for canvassing mail ballots. It has 10 co-sponsors, including three Democrats: Reps. Frank Burns, Ed Neilson and John Inglis III.

The committee vote, May 6, 2025. The State Government Committee first adopted an amendment 26-0, then reported the amended bill 14-12:

  • Yes (14): all 12 Republicans, Reps. Brad Roae, Jacob Banta, Scott Barger, Timothy Bonner, Marla Brown, Russ Diamond, Wendy Fink, Roman Kozak, Stephenie Scialabba, Jeremy Shaffer, Jamie Walsh and Eric Weaknecht, plus two Democrats, Reps. Nancy Guenst and John Inglis III.
  • No (12): Democratic Reps. Carol Hill-Evans, Heather Boyd, Tim Brennan, Nathan Davidson, G. Roni Green, Kristine Howard, Malcolm Kenyatta, Tarah Probst, Benjamin Sanchez, Melissa Shusterman, Ben Waxman and Joe Webster.

Then it stopped. The bill had its first floor consideration May 6, was tabled, came off the table May 7 and got second consideration May 12, 2025, when it was sent to the Appropriations Committee. The bill page shows no action since: 534 days as of Wednesday. There has been no recorded floor vote.

At the time, Republican support for the House bill fell apart before it reached a floor vote, and House Majority Leader Matt Bradford said House Democrats would not allow a vote to put voter ID in the constitution, the Inquirer reported. The WITF/Spotlight report says House Democrats have not sent the Senate a voter ID proposal.

What happens next

The House has two scheduled voting days, Nov. 9 and 10, and the Senate has Nov. 17 and 18, according to the House and Senate calendars. Bills that haven't passed both chambers by Nov. 30 die. A constitutional amendment that passes in 2027 would still need to pass again in 2029 before it could reach the ballot.

None of this changes the rules for Nov. 3. First-time voters at a polling place will be asked for ID; other voters will not, according to the Department of State.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime