A judge ordered a recount in the 41st House District. It starts Monday, with 167 ballots reviewed by hand
Lawyers for Rep. Brett Miller and Democrat Brad Chambers agreed in Lancaster County court Thursday to a machine retally of every precinct. Chambers leads by 28 votes in unofficial results, and the county will hold back certifying this one race.
Lancaster County President Judge Leonard Brown III on Thursday granted the recount petitions filed in all 32 precincts of the 41st state House District, FOX43 reported. Lawyers for Republican Rep. Brett Miller and Democrat Brad Chambers agreed in court that county elections staff should recount the votes, LNP | LancasterOnline reported. The recount begins at 10 a.m. Monday, Nov. 23, at the county Board of Elections office.
Why it matters: this is the closest state House race of the year. Chambers leads 14,291 to 14,263, a 28-vote margin, in unofficial results. Voters in every precinct petitioned, which we reported Thursday may be a first for a legislative race in Pennsylvania. Democrats keep their House majority whichever candidate wins.
How the recount will work
According to LNP, citing the petitioners' attorney, Brian Adrian:
- A machine retally. Staff will run the ballots through different machines than the ones used after polls closed Nov. 3.
- 167 ballots by hand. The petitions also asked the county to review 167 ballots with an undervote or overvote in the race, meaning neither candidate or both were marked. Both sides agreed to count those by hand.
- Both sides have to agree. A vote from one of those ballots will be added only if both parties agree on what the voter meant. Any ballot they disagree on goes back to Brown.
- Observers, no press. Each candidate may have one observer and each party two. Reporters are barred from the room, as they were for the Nov. 5 provisional ballot count.
The county will update its elections page if the totals change, LNP reported. Earlier coverage said the petitions sought a full hand count. The agreement in court limits hand counting to the 167 ballots.
Who was there
Miller attended the hearing. He hasn't spoken publicly about the race since Election Day, and he didn't say whether he would accept the result if the recount confirms Chambers' lead, LNP reported. Chambers wasn't at the hearing and didn't respond to LNP. His attorney, Jason Ulrich, declined to comment. Chambers told Votebeat earlier this week that he would accept the recount's outcome.
Republican voters who signed petitions told LNP that Miller or his campaign asked them to, and that they had no reason to believe there was fraud. The petitions didn't allege fraud. Filing in every precinct is what allowed them to go forward without that allegation, under a 2023 state Supreme Court ruling described in our earlier explainer.
Certification
Monday is also the state's deadline for counties to certify Nov. 3 results. Chief elections clerk Christa Miller told LNP the county will certify its other legislative and federal races by the deadline and is in contact with the Department of State about the 41st. County officials told FOX43 they plan to delay only this race. Results aren't official until the Board of Elections certifies them.
How often recounts change things here
The last recount petitions in Lancaster County followed the May 2022 primary, in the 36th Senate District and the 100th House District. Most of the roughly four dozen petitions were rejected, and the one recount that went ahead, in the 100th, matched the original tally, LNP reported.
The calendar
- Nov. 23, 10 a.m.: recount begins.
- Nov. 30: Miller's current term ends with the 2025-26 session.
- Dec. 1: the winner of the Nov. 3 election takes office.
All figures here are unofficial.