A grand jury found 'failures' at Allegheny County's elder protection agency. The Senate's oversight bills die Nov. 30
The report on an older couple's deaths lands weeks after a state audit questioned how the Department of Aging oversees county agencies. SB 1376 and SB 807 never got a House committee vote.
An Allegheny County investigating grand jury found "patterns of dysfunction" and multiple "failures" at the county's Area Agency on Aging in its handling of abuse and neglect referrals for an older couple who both died in 2025, Spotlight PA reported. District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr.'s office released the 43-page report Wednesday, Nov. 18. The office said it found "major systemic issues."
Why it matters: county aging agencies carry out protective services for older adults under state law, and the state Department of Aging funds and monitors all 52 of them. The report comes weeks after an audit by Auditor General Tim DeFoor said the department's oversight has gaps, a finding the department rejected (our report). Two Senate bills to tighten that oversight are about to die.
What the grand jury found
According to Spotlight PA and WESA, which published the story:
- The wife was referred to the agency six times for suspected neglect or abuse between mid-2024 and mid-2025. She died in July 2025 of sepsis from pressure wounds. Her husband, who had dementia, died in early September 2025 of "a failure to thrive" after neglect.
- Caseworkers took weeks to meet the wife, although state rules require a face-to-face interview within 24 to 72 hours in most cases. One case was closed after a brief interview through a car window, with a family member present.
- The county didn't report the case to law enforcement in time, as state regulations require. Police were notified by medical staff. The report says caseworkers were discouraged from reporting for "political reasons" but doesn't explain them.
- Two private contractors handled the investigations. The county has since stopped using contractors for that work.
The grand jury examined government agencies' failures, not whether anyone should be charged in the deaths. We aren't naming the couple, whom the report doesn't name, or their family members.
The recommendations
The grand jury recommended that the agency:
- coordinate with law enforcement to train caseworkers;
- make it easier for police to get an older adult's protective services file;
- standardize the language in case files; and
- better track and report allegations that could carry criminal penalties.
County Solicitor Rosalyn Guy-McCorkle declined to discuss the findings, citing an "ongoing criminal investigation," and said the agency has already acted on the recommendations.
The state's role
A Department of Aging spokesperson told Spotlight PA the department helped drive recent improvements at the Allegheny agency and is giving it technical assistance. The department scores county cases through a monitoring system it started in early 2025. Gov. Josh Shapiro has declined to release a state inspector general report on the department's oversight of county agencies, calling such reports confidential, Spotlight reported.
What the records add
All three oversight bills from this session are stalled, according to their bill pages, and die when the session ends Nov. 30:
Advertisement
- SB 1376, Sen. Jarrett Coleman's rewrite of the department's duties toward county agencies, passed the Senate 33-16 on Sept. 30. Its last action is "Referred to Aging & Older Adult Services, Sept. 30, 2026."
- SB 807, Sen. Lynda Schlegel Culver's statewide older adult abuse registry, passed 42-8 on Oct. 21. It was referred to the same House committee on Oct. 29 and hasn't moved.
- HB 1611, Rep. Maureen Madden's broader update of the Older Adults Protective Services Act, was last "Laid on the table, Sept. 8, 2026," with no floor vote.
The House's last scheduled session, Nov. 19, had no votes, and the Senate finished its term Nov. 17 (our report). Any of these would have to be reintroduced after the new General Assembly convenes Jan. 5.
Anyone who suspects an older adult is being abused can call the state's 24-hour line at 1-800-490-8505.