On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

General AssemblyRail safety

Four freight derailments in Blair County this year. The state rail safety bill has waited 214 days in a Senate committee

The latest, on Oct. 23 in Altoona, included three tank cars of liquefied petroleum gas. House Bill 1191 passed 120-79 in March; Altoona's former representative also filed a train-length bill that never got a vote.

U.S. Rep. John Joyce (R-13th District) sent letters Monday to the Federal Railroad Administration and Norfolk Southern asking why four freight trains have derailed in Blair County since February, the Altoona Mirror reported. At least 100 rail cars have left the tracks on the Norfolk Southern main line between the Horseshoe Curve area and Altoona's western edge.

Why it matters: the line runs through Altoona and its suburbs. In the most recent derailment, on Oct. 23 near West Pine Avenue in Altoona (Mirror), 10 cars came off the tracks, including three tank cars of liquefied petroleum gas, the paper reported. No leaks or injuries were reported.

What officials have said

Joyce called four derailments in nine months "unprecedented and completely unacceptable," the Mirror reported. He asked the federal agency whether it has flagged the corridor as high risk and whether it has coordinated with the National Transportation Safety Board. He asked the railroad why inspections missed the problems, whether it will reroute hazardous materials, and whether its system for notifying local officials and first responders worked each time.

Local emergency officials told the Mirror the railroad's response has improved but communication is still "a work in progress," in the words of Altoona Fire Chief Adam Free. Some asked for a Norfolk Southern liaison to be sent to every scene automatically.

What the records add

Railroad safety is largely federal, but state lawmakers have tried to add their own rules.

House Bill 1191, from Rep. Rob Matzie (D-Beaver), would cap freight train length, set minimum crew sizes, bar trains from blocking road crossings and require working trackside defect detectors. Our Oct. 28 article covers it in detail.

  • House final passage, March 25, 2026: 120-79. Rep. Scott Barger (R-Blair), whose district includes part of the county, voted no. Rep. Andrea Verobish (R-Blair), who won the Altoona-based 79th District in a March 17 special election, does not appear on that roll call.
  • Senate: referred to the Consumer Protection and Professional Licensure Committee on March 30. No action since: 214 days.

House Bill 539, a train-length limit filed by Altoona's previous representative, Lou Schmitt (R), was referred to the House Consumer Protection, Technology and Utilities Committee on Feb. 10, 2025, and never got a vote. Schmitt resigned Dec. 31 to become a Blair County judge, the Mirror reported. HB 1191 lists him as a co-sponsor.

Blair County's state senator is Judy Ward (R), whose 30th District also covers Fulton, Huntingdon, Juniata and Mifflin counties, according to the Senate member list.

It is not known what caused the Blair County derailments. A former Norfolk Southern engineer told the Mirror the causes may differ from one to the next. Joyce's letters ask the railroad and the federal agency to investigate.

What happens next

The Senate's last scheduled voting days are Nov. 17 and 18 (calendar), and HB 1191 is not on a committee agenda. If it isn't enacted by Nov. 30, it would have to be filed again in January, the third session in a row for the idea.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime