Election 2026Election administration
Bucks County election board case goes before a judge Monday. What's new since the filing, and what the court can and can't do
Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick's petition to remove Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia from the board is set for a 9 a.m. hearing, a day before the vote. The filing itself notes a Republican commissioner endorsed Fitzpatrick while serving on the board in 2018.
A Bucks County judge is scheduled to hear U.S. Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick's petition to remove Democratic Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia from the county board of elections at 9 a.m. Monday, Nov. 2, WHYY reported. That is less than 24 hours before polls open. As of Sunday, no ruling had been reported.
Why it matters: the county board decides disputed ballots and certifies Bucks County's results for governor, the state legislature and Congress, including Fitzpatrick's own race against Democratic Commissioner Bob Harvie in the 1st Congressional District. An Inquirer/New York Times/Siena poll released this week showed Harvie at 48% and Fitzpatrick at 46%, within the margin of error, according to the Inquirer.
Our Oct. 31 article explained the petition and the part of the Election Code that sets who sits on a county board. Here is what has come out since.
New details from the filings and the response
The 2018 precedent is in the petition itself. Fitzpatrick's complaint acknowledges that county commissioners often endorse candidates, including former Republican Commissioner Rob Loughery, who backed Fitzpatrick while serving on the board, WHYY reported. The Bucks County Beacon reported that Loughery marched in a campaign parade for Fitzpatrick that year and that Fitzpatrick did not object at the time.
The demand letter came first. An Oct. 27 letter from Fitzpatrick's lawyer asked Ellis-Marseglia to recuse, alleging "extreme partisan bias," an appearance of impropriety, a due process violation and a likely violation of the state Ethics Act, the Beacon reported. These are allegations; no court or the State Ethics Commission has ruled on them. The petition was filed after she did not step aside by Wednesday afternoon, the Washington Examiner reported.
The county's position. County Solicitor Dan Grieser wrote that a commissioner can be displaced only when she is a candidate, and that the code has no provision for removing one over partisan conduct, WHYY reported. He added that Ellis-Marseglia's support for Democrats is protected speech and that she has voted five times to certify Fitzpatrick's wins.
What party leaders said. State Sen. Steve Santarsiero, who chairs the Bucks County Democratic Committee, predicted the court would "brush aside this frivolous suit," WHYY reported. Bucks County Republican Committee Chairman Ted Christian said voters "deserve full confidence" in unbiased election administration and argued Ellis-Marseglia's conduct raises questions about whether she can be trusted. Fitzpatrick's office did not answer the Beacon's questions, including whether he would accept the result if he loses.
What the records add
The statute is narrow. Section 301 of the Election Code makes the county commissioners the board of elections and provides a substitute only when a commissioner is a candidate. That is why Harvie, as a candidate, is off the board this year. The petition asks the court to go further on due process and appearance-of-impropriety grounds, which the statute doesn't list.
Advertisement
Lawmakers haven't touched board makeup this session. The Election Code bill that moved furthest, House Bill 1396, deals with mail ballots, audits and early voting, not who sits on county boards. It passed the House 102-101 and has been in the Senate State Government Committee since May 22, 2025, according to its bill page.
Courts are open on Election Day. The state's 2026 election calendar notes that county courts of common pleas sit from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. on Nov. 3 to handle election matters, so disputes that arise Tuesday also go before a local judge.
How big the county is. Bucks had 485,983 registered voters as of Oct. 5: 201,808 Republicans, 194,683 Democrats and the rest unaffiliated or in minor parties, according to county figures.
What happens next
The judge can grant the petition, deny it or take no action before Tuesday. Voting proceeds either way: polls are open 7 a.m. to 8 p.m., and mail ballots must reach the county by 8 p.m. The board's work continues after Election Day; counties must certify results to the state by Nov. 23, according to the state calendar. We'll update this story after Monday's hearing.