Reporters retraced a GOP search for noncitizen voters in Chester County. Every voter who answered was a citizen
The county Republican committee flagged more than 180 voters by matching jury-duty records to the voter roll. Votebeat and Spotlight PA repeated the method; none of the 13 who responded was a noncitizen.
A method that the Chester County Republican Committee used to flag more than 180 "potential noncitizen voters" is fundamentally flawed, an analysis by Votebeat and Spotlight PA published Thursday found. When reporters repeated the search and asked the flagged voters about their status, every one who answered was a U.S. citizen.
Why it matters: claims about noncitizen voting are at the center of this fall's election fights, including federal prosecutions in Pennsylvania and a national push for proof-of-citizenship rules. Comparisons like this one can wrongly flag eligible voters, the analysis found. Election Day is Tuesday.
What happened
In August, the county Republican committee sent a letter to the Chester County Board of Elections, Votebeat reported. It had compared the county voter roll with a "non-juror" list: people who were called for jury duty and said they were not citizens, which makes them ineligible to serve. That list is public in Pennsylvania. The committee said it found more than 180 matches and gave county commissioners a spreadsheet.
Votebeat and Spotlight obtained the same list through a public records request and ran their own comparison. They found email addresses for roughly two-thirds of the matched voters and contacted them. Thirteen replied:
- Twelve were naturalized citizens whose naturalization date was on or before the date they registered to vote.
- One was born in the United States.
- One record seemed to show a registration before naturalization. The county traced it to a data-entry error.
No noncitizen voter was confirmed.
Why the matching fails
Non-juror lists don't include birthdates, addresses, or driver's license or Social Security numbers, the analysis found. That means two people with the same name can be confused. The lists can also be out of date: someone who declined jury duty as a noncitizen may have become a citizen later and then registered, which is legal. Reviews in California and Texas reached similar conclusions, Votebeat reported.
"Nonjuror lists are not a useful tool to verify the accuracy of voter rolls," Department of State spokesperson Geoff Morrow said. County spokesperson Andrew Kreider said the county met with the Republican committee in August to explain the limits of list comparisons and will act quickly on "specific and verifiable" accusations of fraud. Jon Veurink, executive vice chair of the county GOP, called the reporters' work "good detective work" but did not say what process the county should follow, according to the analysis.
A national activist, Scott Presler, has said he flagged more than 5,000 Pennsylvania voters this way and plans to check all 67 counties. He has not released results, Votebeat reported.
How this connects to the record
- Federal cases. The U.S. Justice Department has charged several Pennsylvania residents with noncitizen voting this fall. Our Oct. 26 article lays out those cases, and our Oct. 23 article covers the court order halting a federal investigation in the state.
- State bills. The House voter ID bill, HB 771, cleared committee 14-12 and has not had a floor vote, as our Oct. 28 article explains. The only legislation the analysis mentions is the federal SAVE America Act, which Presler has tied to his effort.
What happens next
Voters can check their registration on the Department of State's vote.pa.gov site. Polls are open 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. Nov. 3. Our Oct. 29 article explains how to report intimidation at the polls.