The House voted to close the 'Delaware loophole' in 2025. The bill has sat in Senate Finance for 509 days and dies Nov. 30
HB 1610 pairs combined reporting with faster corporate tax cuts, no state tax on tips and a deduction for overtime. House budget staff scored the corporate changes as raising about $1.1 billion in their first full year.
A report on corporate taxes that ran in the Pennsylvania Capital-Star last week and in The Philadelphia Inquirer on Sunday puts an old Harrisburg fight back in view: whether the state should close what's known as the "Delaware loophole." The House passed a bill to do it in June 2025. It has had no Senate vote, and it dies when the session ends Nov. 30.
Why it matters: the Independent Fiscal Office projects a structural deficit that could top $7 billion by 2030 (our article), and Democrats will write the next budget with majorities in both chambers. How the state taxes multistate companies is one of the few large revenue questions that doesn't involve a new tax.
What the loophole is
A company sets up a subsidiary in Delaware, which doesn't tax royalty income, and has its Pennsylvania operation pay that subsidiary to use its own trademarks. The payments are deducted here, and the profit is booked in Delaware. "Combined reporting" taxes a parent and its subsidiaries as one business. The Capital & Main report cites the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy as counting Pennsylvania among 18 states without it.
The bill: HB 1610
House Bill 1610, from Rep. Elizabeth Fiedler, a Philadelphia Democrat, is broader than combined reporting. The House Appropriations Committee's fiscal note lists five pieces:
- Combined reporting, with faster rate cuts. The corporate net income tax rate, already falling under a 2022 law, would drop faster: to 7.24% instead of 7.49% for 2026, 6.49% instead of 6.99% for 2027, 5.74% instead of 6.49% for 2028, and to 4.99% in 2029, a year early. Staff scored the package as raising $264 million in 2025-26 and about $1.1 billion in 2026-27.
- No state income tax on tips, costing $60.3 million and $67.9 million in those years.
- A deduction for overtime pay, costing $110.2 million in 2026-27.
- Changes to the Working Pennsylvanians Tax Credit, costing $360.2 million and $598.1 million.
- A resident credit for partners and S corporation shareholders, costing $93.8 million in the first year.
The votes
- House Finance Committee: reported June 17, 2025.
- House Appropriations: 22-15 on June 25, 2025.
- House final passage: 104-99 the same day.
- Senate: referred to the Finance Committee June 25, 2025. No committee vote in the 509 days since, according to the bill history.
The bill is not on the Senate's calendar for Tuesday.
The arguments
The Keystone Research Center found corporations' share of general fund tax revenue fell from 30% in 1972 to 12% in 2023-24, the report says. "Right now the tax system in Pennsylvania is really upside down," Fiedler told Capital & Main.
The Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry told House members the bill would make the state less competitive, add complexity and make revenue more volatile, according to the report. "Combined reporting is double taxation," Sen. Greg Rothman, a Cumberland County Republican, told WHTM-TV. "It's going to drive companies out of Pennsylvania."
Advocates' revenue estimates are higher than the House's. The Pennsylvania Policy Center and the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy put worldwide combined reporting, a broader version that includes foreign subsidiaries, at $1.537 billion a year. The House note scores the bill as written, with its faster rate cuts.
What's next
Gov. Josh Shapiro hasn't said whether combined reporting will be part of the 100-day agenda he and legislative leaders plan to release. His next budget proposal comes early next year. A new combined reporting bill would start over in January with a new number, and would need 26 votes in a Senate where Democrats will hold exactly 26 seats.