Election 2026Election administration
Dauphin County caught 10 forged mail ballot applications before any ballots went out. A canvassing contractor now faces charges
The county's election director flagged the signatures the day they arrived. Prosecutors allege a part-time worker for a Florida canvassing firm forged the requests; the firm says it fired her.
Dauphin County election officials spotted 10 forged mail ballot applications as soon as they arrived in September, rejected them and sent them to prosecutors, and no ballots were ever mailed, WITF reported. District Attorney Fran Chardo filed charges Oct. 30.
Why it matters: in the final days of a campaign marked by claims about mail voting fraud, this is a documented case, and it shows how the system is supposed to catch one. The voters whose names were used kept their right to vote, and the attempt never reached a ballot.
What happened
According to WITF's account of the charging documents:
- Sept. 25: 10 mail ballot applications arrived at the Dauphin County elections office. Election Director Chris Spackman noticed the signatures looked suspicious, rejected the applications and referred them to the district attorney.
- The voters: each of the 10 registered voters confirmed the signature and Social Security number on the application weren't theirs. Eight were over 60, the affidavit says.
- Oct. 8: the suspect, a 31-year-old Idaho woman who worked as a part-time contractor for Mobilize the Message, a Florida company that does door-knocking and signature gathering, admitted by phone to forging the signatures, according to the affidavit.
- Oct. 30: prosecutors charged her with 10 felony counts of identity theft, 10 misdemeanor counts of forgery and one misdemeanor election-law count. A warrant was issued because she is no longer in the county.
The charges are allegations; she has not been convicted. We are not naming her because she is a private individual.
The company's lawyer said it "terminated the rogue contractor" and that it doesn't pay contractors based on how many mail ballot applications they collect, WITF reported. Nothing in the filings or official statements indicates the forgeries were politically motivated, according to the station.
What the records add
How applications are checked. Under the Department of State's mail ballot guidance, every application must carry proof of identification, such as a driver's license number or the last four digits of a Social Security number, which county boards verify. Applications are processed in the state's voter registry, known as SURE, and each ballot's status is logged there, feeding the online ballot tracker and emails to voters. In this case, the county flagged the applications because of their signatures, according to WITF.
Other claims checked this fall. This case differs from broader claims about voter rolls. Our Oct. 30 article covered an analysis finding that a search for noncitizen voters in Chester County flagged people who were citizens. In July, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security said as many as 14,576 noncitizens might be registered in Pennsylvania but did not share its list or method, as our Oct. 23 article reported.
What the voters could do. Because the applications were rejected, no ballots were mailed in the 10 voters' names, and they can vote as usual. Had a ballot been sent in a voter's name without their knowledge, state guidance says a voter who requested but didn't return a mail ballot can vote by provisional ballot at the polls, so the county can confirm only one vote counts.
What happens next
The case will proceed in Dauphin County court once the defendant is arrested or appears. Today, anyone who requested a mail ballot and hasn't returned it can surrender it at their polling place and vote, or vote provisionally. Voters can check their mail ballot status at vote.pa.gov and report suspected fraud to their county election office, their district attorney or 1-877-VOTESPA (1-877-868-3772).