Democrats want to repeal the constitution's tax uniformity clause. Under the amendment process, voters couldn't decide before 2029
HB 2807 would delete the clause that has blocked graduated income tax rates. It never got a committee vote and dies Nov. 30; a trifecta can't skip the two-session amendment process.
Pennsylvania taxes personal income at one flat rate, and a single sentence in the state constitution is the main reason it can't easily do otherwise. Some Democrats want to repeal it now that they will control the House, the Senate and the governor's office. A Broad + Liberty report published Thursday lays out why that would take years.
Why it matters: graduated rates, taxing higher incomes at higher rates, have been floated as a way to pay for the trifecta's priorities. Rep. Morgan Cephas, a Philadelphia Democrat, said after the election that repealing the clause would be key, Broad + Liberty reported. The state's Independent Fiscal Office projects a structural deficit above $7 billion by 2030 (our report).
The clause
Article VIII, Section 1 of the constitution reads: "All taxes shall be uniform, upon the same class of subjects, within the territorial limits of the authority levying the tax, and shall be levied and collected under general laws."
State courts have read it to mean income is one class of subject that has to be taxed at one rate. According to Broad + Liberty's review, the state Supreme Court held in 1935 that a graduated income tax violated the clause, and in 1971 it struck down a personal income tax in Amidon v. Kane. More recently it has applied the clause to strike down a gaming tax with variable rates in 2016, a cap on corporate net-loss deductions in 2017 and Pittsburgh's tax on nonresident athletes and performers in September 2025.
The bills
- HB 2807, from Rep. Elizabeth Fiedler, a Philadelphia Democrat, is a joint resolution that would repeal Section 1 outright. It has 24 sponsors, all Democrats, including Cephas. It was introduced and sent to the House Finance Committee on Sept. 28, 2026, and has had no action since. Like every pending bill, it dies Nov. 30.
- In the Senate, Sen. Tim Kearney, a Delaware County Democrat, circulated a co-sponsorship memo in July titled "Creating a Fair Tax System: Uniformity Clause Repeal," Broad + Liberty reported, and Senate Democrats announced in October that he was introducing the amendment (ITEP repost).
Repeal wouldn't set any tax rates. It would remove the barrier; rates would still need a separate law.
Why a trifecta doesn't speed it up
Constitutional amendments don't go to the governor. Under Article XI, an amendment must pass both chambers by a majority of members, be advertised in every county three months before the next general election, pass both chambers again in the next two-year session, and then be approved by voters.
If the 2027-28 legislature passes a repeal, the 2029-30 legislature would have to pass it again before it could go on the ballot. That puts a statewide vote in 2029 at the earliest, the same timeline as the proposed abortion rights amendment (our explainer).
The arguments
David Taylor, president of the Pennsylvania Manufacturers' Association, told Broad + Liberty that "the uniformity clause is a very important institutional barrier to the growth of the state." Kearney, Cephas and Shapiro's office didn't respond to the outlet by its deadline.
Broad + Liberty noted one unsettled question: it found no Supreme Court ruling directly on whether a law taxing wages and investment income at different rates, without repealing the clause, could survive.