McCormick tells Shapiro the 'window is rapidly closing' on the federal scholarship tax credit. Thirty-two states are in; Pennsylvania hasn't decided
Six weeks after Shapiro said he expected to decide 'in the next few weeks,' there's no announcement. Contributions under the program start Jan. 1, and only the governor can opt in.
U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick has written to Gov. Josh Shapiro urging him to opt Pennsylvania into the federal scholarship tax credit, saying the "window of opportunity for Pennsylvania is rapidly closing," PoliticsPA reported. Shapiro still hasn't announced a decision, and the program's first contributions can be made Jan. 1, 45 days from now.
McCormick, a Republican, argued that Pennsylvania "does not need to wait for final regulations," pointing to Treasury guidance that states, scholarship organizations and donors may rely on the proposed rules for gifts made starting Jan. 1, 2027. He also said the state's existing tax credit scholarship programs, the Educational Improvement Tax Credit and the Opportunity Scholarship Tax Credit, give it the infrastructure to start.
Why it matters: under the federal law, the choice belongs to the governor alone. If Pennsylvania stays out, residents can still claim the credit, but their gifts would go to scholarship groups in other states, and Pennsylvania students couldn't receive the scholarships. We explained the program last week.
Where other states stand
As of Nov. 10, according to PoliticsPA:
- 32 states had opted in. Most have Republican governors; Colorado, New Mexico and New York are Democratic-led states that opted in.
- 2 governors vetoed opt-in legislation, and Kentucky's legislature overrode Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear's veto in March.
- 2 states said they won't participate.
- 15 states, Pennsylvania among them, hadn't decided.
What Shapiro has said
Asked about the letter, Shapiro's office pointed to his answer at the Oct. 7 debate: "I'm very open to this," and "I expect in the next few weeks here to be able to make an announcement on opting in or not." Six weeks later, there's no announcement.
Who is pushing, and who is opposed
PoliticsPA reported that Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward, a Republican, posted four social media messages in the past week urging Shapiro to opt in, and that Treasurer Stacy Garrity, who lost to Shapiro, said she hoped he would now that the election is over. The Commonwealth Foundation and the American Federation for Children back the program; the latter estimates about 1.8 million Pennsylvania students could qualify.
Two teachers unions, the Pennsylvania State Education Association and AFT Pennsylvania, oppose it. "Vouchers shift resources away from public schools," PSEA said, according to PoliticsPA.
The legislature can't decide this one
In August, Ward circulated a co-sponsorship memo for a state bill to make Pennsylvania take part, with Republican Sens. Joe Pittman, Scott Martin, Lynda Schlegel Culver and Judy Ward and Democratic Sen. Anthony Williams of Philadelphia. On Tuesday the memo page still said, "This document has not been submitted for introduction yet." With the Senate's last voting days on Nov. 17 and 18 and the session ending Nov. 30, a new bill couldn't pass this year. In January, Democrats control both chambers.
Advertisement
How the credit works
Starting with gifts made on or after Jan. 1, 2027, a taxpayer who gives to a scholarship granting organization gets a federal tax credit of up to $1,700, or $3,400 for a married couple, Metro Philadelphia reported. Families earning under 300% of their area's median income can get scholarships for private school tuition and other costs, such as tutoring and supplies.
Under the federal law, governors have until Jan. 1 to opt in for the first year, Chalkbeat Philadelphia reported.