On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

General AssemblyElections

About 1.5 million independent voters can vote Tuesday but not in primaries. The House's open-primary bill went to a Senate committee Oct. 13

House Bill 280 passed 115-88 with 16 Republican votes. Senate Republican leaders have tied election changes to voter ID, and the session ends Nov. 30.

Pennsylvania voters who aren't registered with a party can vote in Tuesday's general election, but under state law they can't vote in either party's primary. Supporters of changing that argued this week that unaffiliated voters could decide close state Senate races, in a Philadelphia Inquirer commentary from Ballot PA Action, the group backing the change. It estimated about 1.5 million independent voters statewide, roughly one in six registered voters.

Why it matters: Pennsylvania is one of eight states with closed primaries, by the National Conference of State Legislatures' count, as Votebeat reported. The House passed a bill to open them last month; it is now in the Senate with a month left in the session.

What the bill would do

House Bill 280, from Rep. Jared Solomon, a Philadelphia Democrat, would let registered voters with no party affiliation choose one party's primary ballot, Votebeat and Spotlight PA reported. Registered Democrats still couldn't vote in a Republican primary or the reverse, and unaffiliated voters couldn't vote in internal party elections, such as for committee seats.

Unaffiliated voters now make up more than 13% of the electorate, a share that has grown since 2024 while both major parties lost registered voters, Votebeat reported. Estimates of their number vary.

What the records add

The bill's path, from its official history:

  • State Government Committee, May 13, 2025: reported 14-12, then tabled for more than 16 months.
  • Appropriations, Sept. 29, 2026: re-reported 22-15.
  • Final passage, Sept. 29: 115-88. Sixteen Republicans joined 99 Democrats, according to the Inquirer commentary; with 103 Democrats in the chamber, that means four Democrats voted no.
  • Senate: referred to the State Government Committee on Oct. 13. No action since: 18 days.

The bill has 32 co-sponsors. Votebeat described it as the first time in recent memory such a bill passed the House. A 2024 amendment with the same aim passed the House 112-90, and the Senate passed a similar bill 42-8 in 2019, Votebeat reported. Neither became law.

The arguments

Solomon said the bill would bring in new voices and lower the political temperature, Votebeat reported. Rep. Wendy Fink, a York County Republican, said every voter can already take part in a primary by registering with a party, and that primaries are party nominating contests.

Lebanon County's election director warned that counties would need more ballot styles, proofreading and poll worker training, raising the risk of mistakes, according to Votebeat.

Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman, an Indiana County Republican, has said House Democrats' refusal to advance voter ID is blocking broader election changes, and Senate Republicans have insisted election bills be paired with expanded voter ID, Votebeat reported. The House voter ID bill has sat in Appropriations for more than 530 days, as our Oct. 28 article shows. Gov. Josh Shapiro's office declined to say whether he supports HB 280.

What happens next

The Senate's remaining voting days are Nov. 17 and 18 (Senate calendar). The Senate State Government Committee would have to vote the bill out first. If it isn't enacted by Nov. 30, it dies, and the next primary, in May 2027, will be closed. Unaffiliated voters who want to vote in a primary can change their registration through vote.pa.gov.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime