On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

EducationState agencies

The State Board of Education voted down new PSSA and Keystone cut scores, 5-9. Spring test results will be rerun on the old scale

Board members said the plan was rushed and that 2026, the first year of statewide online testing, was the wrong baseline. The department says districts will still get scores, later. Philadelphia's school selection deadline is Dec. 16.

The State Board of Education on Thursday, Nov. 19, rejected the Department of Education's proposal to change the cut scores for the state's math and reading tests. The motion failed 5-9, with one abstention, according to Chalkbeat Philadelphia and a meeting summary from the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators.

Why it matters: about 900,000 students took the PSSA and the high school Keystone exams last spring, and their schools still don't have official results. The department had held the scores back while it proposed the new scale. Now it has to score the tests again under the old one. In Philadelphia, families need those scores to apply to some magnet schools.

What the board turned down

The proposal kept the score needed for "proficient" the same but lowered the bar for "advanced" in nearly every grade, so more students would have been rated advanced (our preview). PSSA cut scores were last set in 2015 and Keystone cut scores in 2012, the department said, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer. About 90 educators worked on the recommendations.

Deputy Secretary Amy Lena told the board the change was needed "to ensure that performance labels accurately reflect what students know and can do," the Inquirer reported.

How the vote broke

The chairs of the House and Senate education committees are voting members of the board. According to Chalkbeat and the Inquirer:

  • Sen. Lindsey Williams, a Pittsburgh Democrat and minority chair of the Senate Education Committee, voted no. "I'm not convinced that 2026, the year when nearly half the students took the test online for the first time and there were tech issues in its administration … is the right year to serve as our baseline going forward," she said. She also said there were "communication breakdowns that happened at multiple points in the process." She and other members said they didn't know the department was pursuing changes until a briefing earlier this month.
  • Sandra Dungee Glenn said she appreciated the educators' work but that "it would be better, more appropriate to do it next year."
  • Rep. Peter Schweyer, a Lehigh County Democrat who chairs the House Education Committee, was the only legislator on the board to vote yes. He said it was "maybe not necessarily the right time," but that "we've gone way too long for addressing these (cut scores) in any kind of systematic or thoughtful manner."
  • Vice Chair Carol Aichele also voted yes. "The whole purpose of having these assessments is to inform instruction for the coming year, and right now we're almost halfway through the current year," she said.

What happens to the scores

"We will just have to go back, we'll have to make sure that we run them under the old (scoring system)," Lena said, according to Chalkbeat. "That will take a little bit of time." The department hasn't said how long. Districts usually receive results in August. Officials had said they would release them within days if the board approved the change.

Philadelphia

The Philadelphia School District has already pushed its school selection deadline back twice, most recently to Dec. 16. It planned to close its application website Nov. 24 to Dec. 2 to load students' scores. Superintendent Tony Watlington has said he doesn't plan to make admission to the criteria-based schools test-optional, Chalkbeat reported. A district spokesperson didn't respond to Chalkbeat's request for comment.

What else the board did

The PASA summary lists other business at Thursday's meeting:

  • The State Board for Career and Technical Education unanimously approved proposed Chapter 761 regulations creating an accreditation process for postsecondary career and technical education.
  • The board's academic standards committee received more than 700 comments at three hearings on Chapter 4 and will take them up at a future meeting.
  • The board discussed Penn State's application to discontinue seven branch campuses at the end of the spring 2027 semester (background).

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime