Labor lawyer Todd Eagen is running for Superior Court in 2027, and former U.S. Rep. Matt Cartwright is weighing a state Supreme Court bid
A Superior Court seat opens because President Judge Anne Lazarus reaches the mandatory retirement age. At least one Supreme Court seat is on the ballot, possibly two.
The 2027 races for Pennsylvania's appeals courts picked up two names this week. Todd Eagen, a labor lawyer, announced on Facebook on Tuesday that he is running for the Superior Court, and former U.S. Rep. Matt Cartwright said he may run for the state Supreme Court, WVIA reported.
Why it matters: the Supreme Court has the last word on challenges to state laws and election rules, and appeals over laws the new Democratic trifecta passes will move through these courts. Judges are elected in partisan races and then face yes-or-no retention votes.
Superior Court: an open seat
A vacancy opens because Superior Court President Judge Anne E. Lazarus turns 75, the mandatory retirement age for Pennsylvania judges, WVIA reported.
Eagen, 59, is a former Dunmore resident who recently moved to Philadelphia. "For the last 30 years I've represented unions all across Pennsylvania," he told WVIA. For the past four years he has served on the state Supreme Court's civil rules committee, which helps set rules for civil cases, and says he has handled cases in about 50 of the state's 67 counties. This is his third run for an appeals court: he lost Democratic primaries for Commonwealth Court in 2015 and 2017. He is a grandson of the late Michael J. Eagen, a former chief justice of the state Supreme Court.
Supreme Court: one or two seats
- Justice Christine Donohue turns 75, opening her seat.
- Chief Justice Debra Todd, 69, is not planning to seek retention, a spokesperson for the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts told WVIA. If she doesn't file, her seat is also open.
- Justices who want to stand for retention must file by Jan. 4.
Cartwright, 65, of Moosic in Lackawanna County, served six terms in Congress and lost his 2024 race to Republican Rob Bresnahan. "I haven't made any decisions at this time," he told WVIA in a text Wednesday. He pointed to Democrats' gains this month, including the flip of Bresnahan's seat by Scranton Mayor Paige Cognetti.
Who else is in
Commonwealth Court Judges Lori Dumas and Matthew Wolf have announced Democratic campaigns for the Supreme Court, and Judge Michael Wojcik is widely expected to run (our report). We found no announced Republican Supreme Court candidates as of Thursday. Our earlier article explains the seats and Justice Sallie Mundy's retention vote.
Key dates
- Jan. 4, 2027: retention filing deadline.
- February and March 2027: nominating petitions circulate.
- May 18, 2027: primary election.
- Nov. 2, 2027: general election and retention votes.