Pennsylvania's next big election is for the Supreme Court: Donohue hits the age limit and Chief Justice Todd isn't seeking retention
Two of the five justices in the court's current majority are leaving, and Justice Sallie Mundy faces a retention vote. One Commonwealth Court judge has announced. The court has the final say on redistricting ties, voting cases and abortion questions.
A week after Democrats won the governor's office and both chambers of the legislature, the next statewide fight is coming into view: the 2027 race for the state Supreme Court. WESA laid out the stakes Friday.
Why it matters: the seven-member court decides challenges to state laws and election rules. It also picks the tie-breaking chair of the commission that redraws state House and Senate districts after the 2030 census, if the four legislative leaders can't agree on one.
Who is leaving, and who is on the ballot
- Justice Christine Donohue must leave the court because she reaches the constitution's mandatory retirement age of 75 next year, WESA reported. Voters retained her for another 10-year term in 2025, along with Justices Kevin Dougherty and David Wecht.
- Chief Justice Debra Todd "is not planning to seek retention in 2027," Stacey Witalec, a spokesperson for the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts, told WESA. Justices seeking retention must file a declaration of candidacy by Jan. 4, so Todd could still change course.
- Justice Sallie Updyke Mundy, elected as a Republican in 2017, faces a yes-or-no retention vote in 2027.
Todd and Donohue were elected as Democrats and are two of the five justices in the court's current majority, with Dougherty, Wecht and Daniel McCaffery. Wecht left the Democratic Party in May 2026, citing concerns about antisemitism, WESA reported. Mundy and Justice Kevin Brobson were elected as Republicans. If Republican nominees win both open seats and Mundy is retained, they would hold four of seven seats.
Open seats are filled in partisan elections: a May primary for each party's nominee, then the November general. Sitting justices run in retention elections without a party label and need a majority of "yes" votes to stay.
Early candidates
- Commonwealth Court Judge Matthew Wolf, elected to that court as a Democrat, announced a run shortly after the Nov. 3 election.
- Commonwealth Court Judge Michael Wojcik, a Democrat and former Allegheny County solicitor, is widely expected to run, according to WESA.
Other Superior Court and Commonwealth Court judges are rumored to be considering bids. WESA did not name any Republican candidates.
"It's even more important now that Republicans challenge the balance of power on the court," state Republican Party spokesman James Markley told WESA. Michael Quatrini, a Pittsburgh-area lawyer and former treasurer of Vote Yes for Fair and Independent Courts, told WESA: "I do think there will be a focus on protecting the right to choose."
Why the court keeps coming up here
The court has been at the center of several stories we have covered this year:
- Mail ballots. A petition over undated mail ballots was pending before the court on Election Day (our article), and close races could still produce litigation (our article).
- Abortion. House Democrats passed a constitutional amendment on reproductive rights, HB 1957, 102-101; it has sat in a Senate committee (our article). A constitutional amendment needs passage in two consecutive sessions and a statewide vote, and lawsuits over amendments often end at the Supreme Court.
- Redistricting. The court chose the chair of the 2021 Legislative Reapportionment Commission after the four caucus leaders deadlocked. The next maps follow the 2030 census, and justices elected in 2027 serve 10-year terms.
- Data centers. WESA notes that local authority to regulate data center construction could also reach the court.
Former Chief Justice Ronald Castille died recently at 82 (our article).
Dates to know
- Jan. 4, 2027: deadline for justices to file for retention.
- May 2027: primary for open seats.
- Nov. 2, 2027: municipal election, with the Supreme Court races and retention questions.