On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

Election 2026Mail ballots

The election is over, but the fight over undated mail ballots isn't. Neither court has ruled, and some House races are within a point

Counties set aside mail ballots with missing or wrong dates on Tuesday. No county count of those ballots has been published yet, the U.S. Supreme Court docket shows no action since June, and the bill to end the rule dies Nov. 30.

Pennsylvania's votes are mostly counted, but one question from Election Day is still open: what happens to mail ballots returned on time in envelopes with no date, or a wrong one. Under state guidance, counties were told to set those ballots aside rather than count or reject them, as our Nov. 3 article explained.

Why it matters: most of the big races weren't close. Gov. Josh Shapiro led by more than 20 points in unofficial returns. But several state House races were within about 1 to 2 points in PoliticsPA's 1:15 a.m. tally, and five House races were still uncalled Wednesday morning, Spotlight PA reported. In a race decided by a few hundred votes, a stack of set-aside envelopes can matter.

What we know, and don't, as of Wednesday

  • No published count yet. We found no county or state figure, as of Wednesday afternoon, for how many ballots were set aside over dates. Allegheny County, for example, reported receiving 140,143 mail and absentee ballots by 8 p.m. Tuesday on its election updates page, but didn't list set-aside ballots.
  • Ballots returned. By 8 a.m. Tuesday, voters had returned 1,114,767 of the 1,315,879 mail ballots sent out, Spotlight reported in its live blog.
  • The canvass is next. Allegheny's board starts its formal canvass, including provisional ballots, Friday, Nov. 6, at 9 a.m., according to the county. Counties must send unofficial results to the Department of State by Nov. 10 and certify by Nov. 23, according to Spotlight PA's results guide.

What the records add

The state's instruction. The Department of State's mail ballot guidance, version 3.4 from Sept. 18, tells county boards to "segregate any ballots enclosed in a declaration envelope that is undated or deemed to have an incorrect date." It says the issue "remains a subject of continued litigation" and encourages counties to consult their solicitors. So what happens next may vary by county.

The U.S. Supreme Court hasn't acted. Pennsylvania's appeal in the federal date case, Eakin, is No. 25-967. The docket's last entries are from June 29, when the court invited the U.S. solicitor general to give the federal government's views. As of Wednesday it lists no brief from the solicitor general and no decision on whether to hear the case. Until the court acts, the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals' 2025 ruling that rejecting ballots over the handwritten date is unconstitutional stands, Votebeat reported at the time.

The docket shows how many parties are involved: county election boards from Philadelphia to Juniata, the national and state Republican parties, and an amicus brief from Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward (R-Westmoreland) and other senators.

The state case is pending too. The guidance also cites Baxter v. Philadelphia Board of Elections, which asks the Pennsylvania Supreme Court whether the date rule violates the state constitution. Votebeat reported when the court took the case in January 2025. We found no ruling.

The bill to end the rule is about to die. House Bill 1396, from Speaker Joanna McClinton (D-Philadelphia), would drop the handwritten date requirement as part of a broader Election Code rewrite. It passed the House 102-101 on May 13, 2025, and has been in the Senate State Government Committee since May 22, 2025, 531 days, with no action since. A separate bill to let counties process mail ballots before Election Day, House Bill 37, is also in that committee. Both die Nov. 30 when the session ends.

Next session. Democrats won majorities in both chambers by AP race calls (see our Senate article). Any new version of these bills would have to be introduced again after the new legislature convenes Jan. 5, 2027, and go through committees in both chambers again.

What happens next

If your mail ballot was set aside or rejected, the state Supreme Court ruled in 2025 that counties must notify voters, and that a provisional ballot cast by such a voter must be counted. You can check your ballot's status at pavoterservices.pa.gov or by calling your county election office or 1-877-VOTESPA. We'll report county counts of set-aside ballots as they're published.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime