Election 2026Election administration
Judge keeps Diane Ellis-Marseglia on the Bucks County election board, saying state law gives him no power to remove her
A Chester County judge rejected Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick's petition Monday, a day before the vote. The ruling leaves the three-member board as it was for counting and certification.
A judge on Monday turned down U.S. Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick's request to remove Democratic Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia from the Bucks County Board of Elections, ruling that Pennsylvania law gives courts no authority to take that step, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported. "Without statutory authority we decline," the judge wrote in a one-page order.
Why it matters: the Bucks board rules on disputed ballots and certifies the county's results, including the 1st Congressional District race between Fitzpatrick, a Republican, and Democratic Commissioner Bob Harvie. Monday's ruling means the board that handles today's ballots is the same one that was in place before the lawsuit. Our Nov. 1 article previewed the hearing; this is the outcome.
What the court decided
Senior Judge Jeffrey Sommer of Chester County heard the case in Doylestown after a Bucks County judge recused himself, the Bucks County Courier Times reported. Fitzpatrick, Harvie and Ellis-Marseglia did not attend the hearing, according to the Courier Times.
According to both papers:
- No legal basis for removal. Sommer cited the state Supreme Court's position that courts can't override the Election Code, which allows board members to be replaced only in narrow circumstances: if they are unqualified, on the ballot, or impeached. Conflicts of interest and ethics complaints aren't among them, the Inquirer reported.
- No due process violation yet. The judge noted the board usually doesn't meet to certify until about a week after Election Day, the Courier Times reported. "At this stage, Ms. Marseglia has not done anything," he said in court.
- Judicial ethics rules don't apply. Sommer questioned the argument that judges' conduct rules should govern board members, who are not part of the judiciary, according to the Courier Times.
Sommer also said he could not rule for Fitzpatrick even if he agreed her conduct looked bad, the Inquirer reported.
What each side argued
Fitzpatrick's lawyer, Geoffrey R. Johnson, argued that the board acts in a quasi-judicial role and that Ellis-Marseglia's open support for Harvie created a conflict that violated Fitzpatrick's due process rights, the Courier Times reported. The petition's claims about her conduct are allegations; the court did not find that she acted improperly.
County Solicitor Dan Grieser, who represented Ellis-Marseglia, did not dispute that she backs Harvie. He argued that she has a First Amendment right to do so and that the suit was premature. "We aren't there yet," he said, according to the Inquirer. He said she removed copies of a newspaper from a county building because of a county policy against partisan material in government buildings, the Courier Times reported.
After the ruling, Johnson said he was "disappointed" but that the judge "has left the door open" to raise bias before the board if specific issues come up, the Inquirer reported. Harvie's campaign criticized the lawsuit, and Bucks County Democratic Chairman Steve Santarsiero, a state senator, called it "frivolous," according to the two papers. The Inquirer did not report whether Fitzpatrick plans to appeal.
Advertisement
What the records add
Who sits on the board this year. Under Section 301 of the Election Code, county commissioners are the election board, and a commissioner who is a candidate is replaced. That is why Common Pleas Judge Jordan Yeager is sitting in for Harvie and chairs the board, alongside Ellis-Marseglia and Republican Commissioner Gene DiGirolamo, the Inquirer reported.
The remedies the county pointed to. Grieser said a candidate who objects to a specific board decision after the election can appeal it to the county court, and that impeachment is the route for removing an official over misconduct, the Inquirer reported. Under Article VI of the state constitution, the state House has the sole power of impeachment, and conviction takes a two-thirds vote of the Senate. No impeachment resolution against Ellis-Marseglia has been reported.
Lawmakers haven't changed board membership rules. House Bill 1396, the broadest Election Code bill this session, deals with mail ballots, audits and early voting, not who sits on county boards. It has been in the Senate State Government Committee since May 22, 2025, according to its bill page.
What happens next
Voting in Bucks County runs until 8 p.m., and the county's court is open until 10 p.m. for Election Day disputes, according to the state's 2026 election calendar. Counties must certify their results to the state by Nov. 23. Any challenge to a specific board decision would go to the county court. We'll report if Fitzpatrick appeals.